Skip to main content

State Significant Development

Assessment

Armidale Battery Energy Storage System

Armidale Regional

Current Status: More Information Required

Interact with the stages for their names

  1. SEARs
  2. Prepare EIS
  3. Exhibition
  4. Collate Submissions
  5. Response to Submissions
  6. Assessment
  7. Recommendation
  8. Determination

Development of a 150 MW battery energy storage facility with associated infrastructure

Attachments & Resources

Notice of Exhibition (1)

Request for SEARs (1)

SEARs (1)

EIS (11)

Response to Submissions (8)

Agency Advice (34)

Amendments (9)

Submissions

Filters
Showing 1 - 20 of 32 submissions
Noel Hicks
Object
NA , New South Wales
Message
I wish to forward an objection to the placement of 936 Lithium batteries on a 2.30 Hectare site, project SSD-23515853, close to Armidale.
Apart from the ludicrous campaign by the Federal and State Governments to provide non reliable renewable power throughout the nation at huge expense to the taxpayer, this installation along with its infrastructure will be a blight on the beautiful New England landscape.
While this strategy will make overseas companies wealthy with a life span of perhaps twenty years for the installation, the energy used in producing these batteries and infrastructure is counter productive in providing a large amount of carbon emission in their production. This is particularly obnoxious, when as part of an overall project the Government cannot give an estimate of what this folly is to cost the nation, for an unreliable power source.
Given the precarious defence situation we now face, why would any government eventually be spending trillions of dollars, weakening our industrial strength and therefore our defence capability on a mad venture?
There are a myriad of reasons why I oppose this development but like most I live in a busy world and I know the Government will continue to waste taxpayers money no matter what the objections.
There is an alternative green source of energy in Nuclear Power which could be used, thus preventing our Australian landscape looking like one huge industrial complex.
Noel Hicks A.M.
Paul Miskelly
Comment
MOSS VALE , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
KOORINGAL , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
John McBratney
Object
LANCEFIELD , Victoria
Message
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
ARMIDALE , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Responsible Energy Development for the New England
Object
BEN LOMOND , New South Wales
Message
attached
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
YARRABIN , New South Wales
Message
I object to the environmental, social and economic destruction this project will cause. I object to hazards to health & life from bushfires. Bushfires & batteries do not mix= toxic.
Stop this madness. Go Nuclear.
Name Withheld
Object
Ben Lomond , New South Wales
Message
It is unethical to pursue the Armidale BESS due to their volatility, their potential fire risk and the toxicity of these systems. The proposed BESS poses a risk to the community's health. The capacity to facilitate reserve electricity supply is minimal and not worth the risk to the livelihood of residents. Furthermore the presence of a BESS will serve to validate extensive transmission capacity that is undesirable and contentious throughout the landscape and local terrain.
The BESS is another link in a chain of proposals that purport to save the planet but fail to adequately account for their contributing damage by the same means of accounting.
Such a project cannot be supported
Pauline Pietsch
Object
SALT ASH , New South Wales
Message
I am opposed to the current push for renewable energy and the need for turbines, solar panels and battery storage, if it was so wonderful and it worked there would be no need for tax payer subsidies, it will not reduce consumer power prices and it will destroy the rural landscape and present a danger to wild life.
Name Withheld
Object
LAKE ALBERT , New South Wales
Message
I Object to this Environmentally Contaminating, Public Health & Safety Risk - Ticking Time Bomb Armidale BESS Plan!
This Filthy, Toxic Fire Risk will inevitably result in Industrial Manslaughter charges!

You’d have to be bonkers to imagine this incapable junk will ever work or believe the Fake Green Solar/Wind/BESS Grift & Ponzi Scheme/Scam would deliver “reliable, cleaner, more affordable electricity and a system Australia can count on.”
That would be hilarious if it wasn’t SO diabolically disastrous!
The Developer is planning 150 MW of NON-SUSTAINABLE RENEWABULL JUNK & A DARK
FUTURE - A RUINOUS TRANSITION TO EXTINCTION!
Jeanine Bird
Object
LEETON , New South Wales
Message
Please see attachment
Attachments
Anthony Poole
Object
TORONTO , New South Wales
Message
With current technologies, batteries are an inefficient, unreliable, expensive, and environmentally damaging.
Name Withheld
Object
GUYRA , New South Wales
Message
I Object To Armidale East BESS
You must be Joking to put a Toxic Infrastructure above a Significant Sacred Area , and a National Park, and a World Heritage Listed Area of the Rare Type of Rainforest named Gondwana, already under Threat from Armidale Regional Council, correct.
BESS create Toxic environments. How Dare You offer them to Upper Tributary Catchments of the Macleay System. Catchments flow subsurface into Gorges under Protection, under Protection. Under Protection. Macleay River Catchments are not protected, Why?
Macleay catchments need Protection.
And they do.
Do
World Heritage Listed Gondwana Rainforests need a State Significant Listing. Cease and Desist this farcical “clean energy transition” idea immediately.
Bayley Park is it? Pin Pot Crk is it? Or Limerick Crk? Macleay Upper Catchments. Stop it. Stop it. Stop this Toxic Future claiming “clean energy”.
• 500MW BESS including: Bttery containers inverters transformers fire suppressions systems new access road to the site etc
Armidale East BESS
Um. If you are Aware, then don’t do this.
BESS will Increase anywhere Renewables are. I don’t want Renewables
Anywhere, you see. Nowhere.
Do you understand,hm?
What about this as a Solution - Rooftops. Off Grid. Subsidised by our
government as a Low Cost Solution to energy generation, from Rooftops, All.
All. Plenty of Jobs,hm, yeah, plenty.
I Vehemently Protest Excess Emission Australian Government State
Government Takeover of Vital areas, Vital to Next 8 Generations.
Excess Emissions government I need Investigated for Harm and Loss To,
creating Excess Emission Future all over Planet Earth. I therefore Demand a

Royal Commission into Renewables and Transmission Lines we, in the
country, should not be exposed to. Shouldn’t be exposed to.
I am Very Upset with gov.au, and the way it is. Is. Who is it, I continually ask?
Well? Who are you, gov.au, Corporate Entity as a Sharemarket Enterprise
that’s Costing your dear population in many ways you have No care about.
No care about. I therefore Demand a Royal Commission into Renewables
and Transmission Lines that are Wrong for rural Australia, you see. Why
aren’t you all putting power on your Own Rooftops, if you want So much, in a
Climate Emergency? I have a need, and it is an Investigation into an Agenda
called Climate Change. I know what it’s about and you do not, gov.au, and I
need you in an investigation Immediately, so we can get Together and All
Discuss OUR Future, you see.
What is OUR Future?
Mine, and Aussies Future, not Agenda gov.au into US militiary into the China-
Make-It-All future that Destroys Environment, and It Is Environment
Destroyed, and For No Reason Destroyed, and I am very Angry it is Being
Destroyed For No Reason At All.
My Dry Continent is a Mine Pit for No-One.
My Dry Continent is under Immense Threat to Environment that Includes a
area in QLD that will be Necessary into our Next 8 Generations from Now.
Now being those as 18 years olds 8 th Generational Future. Which will need
the Environment Nature made you see.
What is it you want, government, Australian into State, into Minister for? What
is it you want? Jobs is it? I can give you Jobs that bring a Benefit to Everyone
called Australian, and those here Now, needing to be offering a futuristic Plan
for Environment, in a Dry Continent, that Needs our Help and Care and
Awareness about.
My government, Australian, State, Local Minister, into Mayors choosing
Agenda 2030 2045 2050 future, Must be under an Investigation for Incrrease
In Emissions into 2080, I predict, predict.
Get Off My Nation, gov.au, you Add More Harm To. I need you to Stop it now,
gov.au.
Solar Farms. Put them On Rooftops Government. Leave Land Free of
Infrastructure Not Needed On Country on a Dry Continent in a Drought at this
time, gov.au.

Put these things On Rooftops. Won’t need a BESS. Thanks. Save a Lotta
Money gov.au, who Waste our Money, and Need to be under Investigation for
actions they undertake Without Ever Ever discussing OUR Future, mind You,
OUR Future we all need to Have A Say in, and can never ever get one, can
we, gov.au, who are Who?
Who are you, gov.au? I need a Royal Commission into All Departments of
Government plus Local of Course. That means you Mr Marshall. You
responsible for everything we are experiencing at this time of High Cost
Living and Drought, and who Suffers but our Farmers, you are Ignorant
about.That is Correct, it is.
God Made us just to experience Life on Planet Earth. What do we do while
here? We Take Take Take and Never give Back to a Dear Planet, the Only
One With Life, the Only One that can’t Awaken The Dumbest Cruelist
Ignorant Abusive being in a Human form, Destroying All Life for No reason
but Money, and it Is that Reason, Is.
God Made this Planet. Respect it, Please. Respect it, please. Human
Impacts are Increasing in your so called Net Zero Agenda. It’s so bloody
obvious it’s an Agenda, making Profit, at a Loss to Many. Yes, many. Where
do you get your Food from? Do you know? Don’t think so. Why are you doing
this to farmland, the next 8 generations will need, don’t you understand?
Gov.au, understand 8 th Generation.
I Demand a Royal Comission into Renewables and Transmission Lines and
BESS, as Infrastructure Not Needed at all. I want a Less Is Best Net Zero. It’s
possible. Cease and Desist AI future now. Get outside and Plant Trees.
That’s what this Planet Needs. Trees. Trillions and Trillions and Infinite
numbers replanted on a Dry Continent missing them, Taken Away by So
Many, rather than us planting them back, to Help a Dry Continent run a Water
Cycle we are Impacting, All.
Get Awake. Go and Walk Country. Get a Better Look at it. You will See the
Impacts Increasing that Increase Threat to Environment.
What is Environment? You don’t even know what it is, gov.au, all
departments, who keep Adding More Impacts to this Dry Continent needing a
new Direction from now. What will it be? Care ? Yeah. Care. Yeah. Care for
Country and All On Country. Mob always did. Always. For 67,473 years they
lived on it without harming it, a Dry Continent. Look at it now. Let us go
toward a Care for Country Future to Benefit The All On Country. It’s Tree
Planting for Jobs. Green Armies of Aussies planting Trees to assist

Productivity of a Dry Continent this government cause Harm and Cause Loss
To each and Every day, just for Money.
Green Armies of Locals all over Australia planting Trees they grow for
Farmland, to assist the Climate in areas now so Different they aren’t their
Climate any more. Eg Northern Tablelands. Was a Cool Climate region. Was.
Unfortunately, Minister Marshall came along and Took it all away. Took what
away. Cool Climate. Why? He’s Ignorant, like All in gov.au, Ignorant and
Unaware of a Dry Continent that will Dry Drought more and more unless we
Plant the Trillions Of Trees She needs ever so much upon Her. What else is
missing on the Northern Tablelands, Watershed to the New England, into
Gwydir Wetlands, and into Pilliga Artesian Basin, under Threat from a Big
Dollar company, Santos, that has NO Respect for Mob at all, named
Kamilaroi et al. Clans say so. What. Santos is not Caring for Country in the
Artesian Basin where the Darling Food Bowl is, didn’t you know, government,
Australian, State, local, Mayor, Councillor of.
Toxicity is Increasing, Not Decreasing, upon a Poor Planet of Earth in Name.
Why is it Increasing, and not Decreasing, government, all, Australian.
God. Wake them up, for they know Not what they do. Cease Harm and Loss
To what’s left as Environment, now under Threat from Next Idea gov.au,
world, Big Dollar, and all those ones doing all the dealing that Takes OUR
Nation into Deeper Debt. Who Pays eventually? We do. We. All Aussies are
Paying a Huge price for your Mistakes you will Never Ever admit to.
BESS Ban - All. Infrastructure will Not be a Need very soon.
Infrastructure will not be a Need soon.
Our government will be Different. I pray for that, I do.
I Demand a Royal Commission into Renewables and Transmission Lines and
BESS and Hydrogen, for God’s Sake, ohh For God’s Sake! Do you know
what that does anywhere it is. No, you don’t, and Don’t care, do you. You
don’t care. Then Get Out of My Nation I need cared for. All of you, and that’s
you too, Mr Marshall, are Ignorant about this Nation, once Wetlands and
Forests, Untouched and Offering the Floodplains catchments to both seas of
Australia. Can’t you see what you’re doing to this Dry Continent, gov.au. Go
and Have a Look please. Not at a Screen. Not there. Go and have a Look at
your Nation you harm and Cause Loss To. What’s dying ? Need a reply.
I need you all Awake. Over Christmas, take some drives.See what is really
happening On Country you have Never even looked at.

Love is The Future. Love is. Love. It was here for 8,027 years, on Planet
Earth. What happened? 2,884 years ago, We stopped moving. Try and
understand what that means please gov.au. This poor Land, named Australia,
Never Gets a Rest, Never, Ever.
Drought is Not normal here. White Man Created it. Won’t stop creating it. So
Stop it, gov.au, Now.
BESS is a Toxic Idea. It is Toxic and Flammable. You should know that,
Should. The simple Solution is Rooftop Power on Every single Roof here
now, and built from now, with a Combination of Bladeless Wind Turbines and
Limited Solar, Tubes please, tubes, yes, they work.
Ban government from My Nation I need under Care please. Under Care
please. It’s Sacred you know.
Attachments
Jill Kerr
Object
NELSON BAY , New South Wales
Message
I Object to Armidale BESS SSD-23515853 as there is too much data to suggest that the current state of 'green renewables' are in fact not green at all. They cause local environmental carnage and will result in Australia having expensive, unreliable power in the future. That is fact, not political spin.
Janet Starr
Object
LEMON TREE PASSAGE , New South Wales
Message
I object to the Armidale BESS as it is unreliable, unsustainable, and environmentally damaging and is not in the best interests of our country. This project will result in higher electricity costs to consumers and batteries have been proven to increase the risk of fire that can not be easily extinguished. Australians want 24/7 energy supply.
Name Withheld
Object
COONABARABRAN , New South Wales
Message
I OBJECT TO THIS PROJECT. These projects are environmentally destructive. There is NO proof that renewable energy will have capacity to power our nation. This is an unreliable energy source. These terms have been dictated to us by international ‘leaders’ who the Australian public - in this case, rural Australia - have not voted for. The Australian government is getting their orders from un-elected internationals who have no care for rural Australia. This is a scam. Why should rural Australia suffer? This is unfair and will ruin rural Australia. Renewable energy is too unreliable. We need to preserve the land that produces our food.
Name Withheld
Object
COONABARABRAN , New South Wales
Message
I object. This will have too many negative impacts on the community. The fire risks and smoke toxicity alone should be enough to have this project cancelled. It is not safe.
Name Withheld
Object
MOLLYAN , New South Wales
Message
I object. I am an 4th generation farmer and agricultural land should not be permanently destroyed to host/house/harbour these projects. I fear for our agricultural industry should all these projects go ahead. Where do those in the cities who agree to/design and develop these projects think their food comes from? Their woke, unreliable ideologies have no place on primary farming land.
What happens when this BESS catches fire? What about toxic run-off from this? What about the toxic chemicals that enter our soil? What about toxic run-off into water systems?
This projects needs to be cancelled due to the disastrous environmental and health impacts.
Name Withheld
Object
MOLLYAN , New South Wales
Message
I object to Armidale BESS. This project is nothing but an unethical cog in a giant scam wheel where international corporations and governments will profit off our loss of primary producing agricultural land. Where rural Australians suffer, these internationals will gain. How can this be allowed?

Why is our government forcing UNRELIABLE energy on our nation at the expense of rural Australia?!?

There needs to be an unbiased Royal Commission into the entirety of the renewable energy industry. Overlords are bullying rural Australians and taking our land.
Save our food producing land! Put these elsewhere! These projects are destroying rural Australia!!
Name Withheld
Object
MOLLYAN , New South Wales
Message
This project is simply unsafe for the community, therefore I object to the Armidale BESS. The smoke and fire risk is significant; in the event of a fire, the smoke would be toxic for all surrounding humans, animals and nature. This is a project that is 100% reliable on the weather, and given the weather is unreliable, this form of energy and storage is also unreliable.

The community were NOT consulted when their region got rezoned to that of an industrial renewable energy zone. This was a biased process NOT in favour of the community.

It reserve the right to add to my objection at a later stage.

Pagination

Project Details

Application Number
SSD-23515853
Assessment Type
State Significant Development
Development Type
Electricity supply
Local Government Areas
Armidale Regional

Contact Planner

Name
Pragya Mathema