Mark Burgess
Object
Mark Burgess
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
I live in Royalla Country estate.
My objections to the proposed new Monaro Rock Quarry is as follows
1 -Transportation, The movement of up to 500 Heavy truck movement per day, six days per week on a country road.(Old Cooma road)
This road is used every day by motor cars and a lot of heavy vehicles, adding more movements of heavy vehicles weighing up to 50.5 tonnes and 20 meters in length. I can see a recipe for accidents to happen. Putting trucks with these lengths and weights on a road never designed for this type of truck movements
Old Cooma road is a narrow road and has tight turns, Crossing over a unused railway line before entering a very busy Monaro highway .(A lot of passenger vehicles use this Highway every day} This intersection has been known to have accidents and a lot of close calls.
Also as a rate payer in the Queanbeyan Palerang council area will I be required through rate increases to pay for the extra damage done to Old Cooma road.
2- Environment
Where I live in Royalla, my houses is also already covered in dust from an operating Quarry in Willimsdale. I can hear the rock crushing plant operating and the blasting of rock. So approving another Rock quarry so close to one already operating will put my property in the middle of extra exposure to more dust and noise
I'm also concerned about the destruction of the hill known as Enchanted hill, this hill to covered in Flora and fauna that is unique to this area.
A another concern is the amount of electricity and water to operate such a large Quarry, Groundwater will not be sufficient to even to try to keep dust down. This will also affect the water table in the area.
3- Economics
This quarry will only benefit two wealthy family's with minimal economic benefit to Queanbeyan community.
We already have Four Quarries in a 30km radius of this proposed quarry, That have a life span of at least 100years.
4- Social
This proposed quarry will affect up to 49,000 people and more in the future.
So I believe the monetary benefit of the few, should not outweigh the benefit of the majority.
Finally I moved to a country estate for my mental and physical wellbeing.
I already suffer though the dust and noise and extra traffic from one operating quarry near me . I don't support approval for another one so close to an operating quarry in a region that is already well serviced by quarries.
My objections to the proposed new Monaro Rock Quarry is as follows
1 -Transportation, The movement of up to 500 Heavy truck movement per day, six days per week on a country road.(Old Cooma road)
This road is used every day by motor cars and a lot of heavy vehicles, adding more movements of heavy vehicles weighing up to 50.5 tonnes and 20 meters in length. I can see a recipe for accidents to happen. Putting trucks with these lengths and weights on a road never designed for this type of truck movements
Old Cooma road is a narrow road and has tight turns, Crossing over a unused railway line before entering a very busy Monaro highway .(A lot of passenger vehicles use this Highway every day} This intersection has been known to have accidents and a lot of close calls.
Also as a rate payer in the Queanbeyan Palerang council area will I be required through rate increases to pay for the extra damage done to Old Cooma road.
2- Environment
Where I live in Royalla, my houses is also already covered in dust from an operating Quarry in Willimsdale. I can hear the rock crushing plant operating and the blasting of rock. So approving another Rock quarry so close to one already operating will put my property in the middle of extra exposure to more dust and noise
I'm also concerned about the destruction of the hill known as Enchanted hill, this hill to covered in Flora and fauna that is unique to this area.
A another concern is the amount of electricity and water to operate such a large Quarry, Groundwater will not be sufficient to even to try to keep dust down. This will also affect the water table in the area.
3- Economics
This quarry will only benefit two wealthy family's with minimal economic benefit to Queanbeyan community.
We already have Four Quarries in a 30km radius of this proposed quarry, That have a life span of at least 100years.
4- Social
This proposed quarry will affect up to 49,000 people and more in the future.
So I believe the monetary benefit of the few, should not outweigh the benefit of the majority.
Finally I moved to a country estate for my mental and physical wellbeing.
I already suffer though the dust and noise and extra traffic from one operating quarry near me . I don't support approval for another one so close to an operating quarry in a region that is already well serviced by quarries.
Susan Luke
Object
Susan Luke
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
The proposed Monaro Rock quarry near Royalla concerns me greatly.
As a recent resident of this area, I moved here for the rural and peaceful lifestyle.
My main concern with the new quarry is that an area listed as Ru2 or C2 Protected land could be utilised for a rock quarry, concrete and asphalt production. I am disappointed that even preliminary assessments and drilling has occurred on protected land within the Queanbeyan-Palerang Council. As a teacher of environmental sciences for many years, I am aware of the damaging and negative impacts that will result from this quarry.
My second concern is the long-term health impacts from silica dust landing on the rooftops of residences. Given the rural nature of Royalla, our primary source of water is collected from our rooftops. Other health concerns include a documented increase in a number of cancers in areas close by quarries in Australia.
My third concern is the effect on traffic on the Monaro Highway and the associated increased risks of accidents.
I am also concerned that this projected has been deemed a State Significant Project, which means that consideration has been taken out of the hands of our local council. It seems that the financial gain from this project will go to two companies, and not necessarily be significantly beneficial to NSW at all. I imagine most of the rock extracted from the quarry will be used in places like the Molonglo Valley. This rock could be sourced from existing quarries in NSW with additional transport costs associated. This seems a better idea than a new build quarry in the middle of tens of thousands of residents.
As a recent resident of this area, I moved here for the rural and peaceful lifestyle.
My main concern with the new quarry is that an area listed as Ru2 or C2 Protected land could be utilised for a rock quarry, concrete and asphalt production. I am disappointed that even preliminary assessments and drilling has occurred on protected land within the Queanbeyan-Palerang Council. As a teacher of environmental sciences for many years, I am aware of the damaging and negative impacts that will result from this quarry.
My second concern is the long-term health impacts from silica dust landing on the rooftops of residences. Given the rural nature of Royalla, our primary source of water is collected from our rooftops. Other health concerns include a documented increase in a number of cancers in areas close by quarries in Australia.
My third concern is the effect on traffic on the Monaro Highway and the associated increased risks of accidents.
I am also concerned that this projected has been deemed a State Significant Project, which means that consideration has been taken out of the hands of our local council. It seems that the financial gain from this project will go to two companies, and not necessarily be significantly beneficial to NSW at all. I imagine most of the rock extracted from the quarry will be used in places like the Molonglo Valley. This rock could be sourced from existing quarries in NSW with additional transport costs associated. This seems a better idea than a new build quarry in the middle of tens of thousands of residents.
Rodney Luke
Object
Rodney Luke
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
I would like to express my deep concern at the proposal for the Monaro Rock Quarry in my local suburb of Royalla. My concerns relate to the process that has been followed which provides little confidence that all appropriate factors have been or will be considered. In addition, the potential health implications facing the 49,000 households and 17 schools located within the likely area of hazard from the quarry should in itself preclude any further consideration of the proposal. Traffic implications on the Monaro Highway leading into Canberra are also of major concerns. This stretch of road is already considered to pose heightened safety concerns. To add the volume of heavy vehicle traffic generated by the quarry will exacerbate what is already recognised as a dangerous section of roadway. I am hopeful that proper consideration of these concerns along with those being voiced by so many residents who stand to be adversely impacted will result in cancelation of the quarry proposal. Should the proposal be progressed further be assured I will be submitting a comprehensive expression of concerns at whatever level of authority is deemed appropriate to ensure that the quarry proposal is appropriately refused.
R.F. Luke AM
Air Commodore RAAF (Retired)
R.F. Luke AM
Air Commodore RAAF (Retired)
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
I'm writing to highly object to the proposal of the Monaro Rock Quarry. I have grown up here in Royalla, this is my home. The peace, quiet and enjoyment of living in the country as a young adult will be removed if we let this quarry go ahead. I am highly concerned about the heavy vehicles and increased traffic that will occur and I feel this is a huge safety concern not to mention the impact it will have on our environment, water quality and health. I live close to the proposed site and I really feel the impact on our lifestyle, health and environment really needs to be considered. This quarry should NOT be allowed to go ahead here in Royalla. There will be so many communities affected by this, it is pure greed and should not be considered at all! I drive on Old Cooma Rd and Monaro Hwy on a daily bases, we deal with holiday traffic regularly, not to mention the snow traffic. Adding an extra 500 trucks a day will be catastrophic! Please take all our concerns into consideration, this quarry is not even needed!!
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
I object based on the following:
The negative air quality, noise, odour effect on the current 49,000 population (expected to grow to 69000 over the next 10 years) in the close proximity to the proposed facility.
The high concern around safety for local residents with the rapid increase of truck volume into and out of the facility and onto the local roads that are already breaking down and under maintaned.
The existing flow of local traffic already see signifcant bottlenecks regularly occuring due to snow traffic. The proposed significant traffic increase is expected to create gridlock at certain times.
The massive financial cost increase in road upgrades and maintenance over the life of this facility will impose an unreasonable financial burden on local ratepayer with little or no benefit to them.
The negative air quality, noise, odour effect on the current 49,000 population (expected to grow to 69000 over the next 10 years) in the close proximity to the proposed facility.
The high concern around safety for local residents with the rapid increase of truck volume into and out of the facility and onto the local roads that are already breaking down and under maintaned.
The existing flow of local traffic already see signifcant bottlenecks regularly occuring due to snow traffic. The proposed significant traffic increase is expected to create gridlock at certain times.
The massive financial cost increase in road upgrades and maintenance over the life of this facility will impose an unreasonable financial burden on local ratepayer with little or no benefit to them.
Sarah Gowland
Object
Sarah Gowland
Object
GOOGONG
,
New South Wales
Message
Dear Planning Authority,
I am writing to formally object to the proposed quarry development due to its severe and unacceptable impacts on the environment, public health, and local community.
The project poses an immediate threat to the environment. It will destroy 22.44 hectares of critically endangered Box-Gum Grassy Woodland—a vital habitat for over 30 species of flora and fauna. The quarry would also extract up to 42.4 million litres of groundwater annually, reducing flows in local watercourses that lead to Tuggeranong and risking widespread pollution from equipment washing and concrete recycling. The groundwater in this region is already depleted with individual property based bores already limitied/not allowed so why is this type of water use even being considered.
The quarry will significantly harm our community, especially through increased traffic and congestion. The project is projected to generate up to 500 heavy vehicle movements per day, creating a major safety hazard on the Monaro Highway and other local roads. This influx of heavy vehicles will cause significant traffic congestion, particularly during peak season like the winter ski season, when traffic volumes on the Monaro Highway are already at their highest.
The community also risks suffering from respirable silica dust, which poses known and serious health risks, not to mention the persistent odours from hot mix asphalt production. Blasting will cause noise and vibrations, and the project's high energy demands could lead to brownouts damaging household appliances. This industrial operation is completely inappropriate for a residential area with 49,000 people living within 10 km, a population projected to grow to 69,000.
Finally, the project is economically and culturally unjustified. On-site surveys have found culturally significant Indigenous artifacts, including ring and scar trees, which would be destroyed by the development. Furthermore, there is no economic need for a new quarry, as four existing quarries within 30 km have the capacity to meet demand for over 100 years. Why is another one even being considered?
In conclusion, this proposal is a direct threat to our environment, health, and cultural heritage, with no clear economic justification. I urge you to reject this development.
I am writing to formally object to the proposed quarry development due to its severe and unacceptable impacts on the environment, public health, and local community.
The project poses an immediate threat to the environment. It will destroy 22.44 hectares of critically endangered Box-Gum Grassy Woodland—a vital habitat for over 30 species of flora and fauna. The quarry would also extract up to 42.4 million litres of groundwater annually, reducing flows in local watercourses that lead to Tuggeranong and risking widespread pollution from equipment washing and concrete recycling. The groundwater in this region is already depleted with individual property based bores already limitied/not allowed so why is this type of water use even being considered.
The quarry will significantly harm our community, especially through increased traffic and congestion. The project is projected to generate up to 500 heavy vehicle movements per day, creating a major safety hazard on the Monaro Highway and other local roads. This influx of heavy vehicles will cause significant traffic congestion, particularly during peak season like the winter ski season, when traffic volumes on the Monaro Highway are already at their highest.
The community also risks suffering from respirable silica dust, which poses known and serious health risks, not to mention the persistent odours from hot mix asphalt production. Blasting will cause noise and vibrations, and the project's high energy demands could lead to brownouts damaging household appliances. This industrial operation is completely inappropriate for a residential area with 49,000 people living within 10 km, a population projected to grow to 69,000.
Finally, the project is economically and culturally unjustified. On-site surveys have found culturally significant Indigenous artifacts, including ring and scar trees, which would be destroyed by the development. Furthermore, there is no economic need for a new quarry, as four existing quarries within 30 km have the capacity to meet demand for over 100 years. Why is another one even being considered?
In conclusion, this proposal is a direct threat to our environment, health, and cultural heritage, with no clear economic justification. I urge you to reject this development.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
Submission to Oppose the Proposed Monaro Rock Quarry
To whom it may concern,
I am writing to formally oppose the development of the Monaro Rock Quarry for the following key reasons:
1. Environmental Impact
The proposed quarry site is located in an ecologically sensitive area that could suffer irreversible environmental damage. This region is home to diverse flora and fauna, some of which are at risk of being endangered. The operation of the quarry would significantly degrade the quality of surrounding ecosystems.
Air and Water Pollution: Dust generated by quarrying operations, along with chemicals and runoff from the site, could contaminate both the air and water sources in the area. This would impact the health of the community, and the quality of life for those living nearby. The use of up to 42.4 million litres bore water, which is required for dust suppression and concrete and asphalt production, by the quarry will also deplete the underground water supply to all living in the area.
Habitat Destruction: The clearing of land to establish the quarry could displace species that rely on the area for food, shelter, and migration paths. This could lead to a loss in biodiversity, disrupting the balance of the local ecosystem.
2. Impact on Local Communities
The development of the quarry threatens to alter the character of the surrounding communities. The increased industrial activity, noise pollution, and traffic congestion will harm the quality of life for residents.
Noise and Vibration: The blasting, machinery, and other operations associated with the quarry would generate noise and vibrations, which would affect both human health and the well-being of all animals. These disturbances could lead to long-term stress on individuals, particularly for families with young children, the elderly, and people with existing health conditions.
Traffic and Safety Concerns: The influx of heavy trucks and machinery, up to 500 trucks per day, required to transport materials from the quarry would significantly increase road traffic, posing safety risks and disrupting daily life for local residents. This increased traffic flow could also result in more frequent accidents and an overall deterioration in road conditions. The Monaro Highway is already a high risk road, especially during the snow season.
Property Values: The presence of a quarry will decrease property values in the surrounding areas, affecting homeowners. This loss in value will make it difficult for local families to maintain their homes and sell their property.
3. Health Risks for Immunocompromised and Vulnerable Individuals
The proposed Monaro Rock Quarry poses a serious public health risk, particularly to immunocompromised individuals and others with pre-existing medical conditions. These members of our community are especially vulnerable to environmental pollutants, and the introduction of large-scale quarry operations could significantly compromise their health and safety.
Airborne Particulates: Quarry operations produce fine particulate matter from blasting, crushing, and transportation of rock. These particles can be inhaled into the lungs and bloodstream, triggering severe respiratory issues. For immunocompromised people — including those undergoing cancer treatment, living with autoimmune diseases, organ transplant recipients, and others — this exposure can lead to chronic inflammation, infections, or hospitalization.
Increased Respiratory and Cardiovascular Risk: Quarry-related air pollution has been linked to exacerbated asthma, bronchitis, and cardiovascular issues — all of which pose a heightened danger to vulnerable individuals. The stress of chronic exposure to airborne pollutants can lower immune system effectiveness, leading to more frequent and severe illnesses.
Lack of Escape: Unlike healthy people who may tolerate or adapt to increased dust and pollution, immunocompromised people often do not have the option to safely remain in affected areas. This could force them to relocate, resulting in economic and emotional hardship.
Including vulnerable populations in planning and risk assessments is a legal and moral obligation. Proceeding with this quarry without adequately protecting the health of immunocompromised individuals would be a violation of public health responsibilities.
4. Community Opinion
With approximately 49000 people living within 10klm of the proposed site, and with the projected number around 69000 in the next 10 years, it is essential to recognise the voices of the community who have expressed opposition to this proposal. Local residents, businesses, and environmental advocates have raised significant concerns about the quarry’s potential effects. Ignoring the concerns of the people who live and work in the region would harm our community.
Conclusion
Given the significant environmental risks, adverse impacts on local communities, and the potential for long-term economic harm, I urge the relevant authorities to reject the proposal for the Monaro Rock Quarry. The preservation of our environment and community well-being, must take precedence over short-term industrial interests.
Thank you for considering this submission.
To whom it may concern,
I am writing to formally oppose the development of the Monaro Rock Quarry for the following key reasons:
1. Environmental Impact
The proposed quarry site is located in an ecologically sensitive area that could suffer irreversible environmental damage. This region is home to diverse flora and fauna, some of which are at risk of being endangered. The operation of the quarry would significantly degrade the quality of surrounding ecosystems.
Air and Water Pollution: Dust generated by quarrying operations, along with chemicals and runoff from the site, could contaminate both the air and water sources in the area. This would impact the health of the community, and the quality of life for those living nearby. The use of up to 42.4 million litres bore water, which is required for dust suppression and concrete and asphalt production, by the quarry will also deplete the underground water supply to all living in the area.
Habitat Destruction: The clearing of land to establish the quarry could displace species that rely on the area for food, shelter, and migration paths. This could lead to a loss in biodiversity, disrupting the balance of the local ecosystem.
2. Impact on Local Communities
The development of the quarry threatens to alter the character of the surrounding communities. The increased industrial activity, noise pollution, and traffic congestion will harm the quality of life for residents.
Noise and Vibration: The blasting, machinery, and other operations associated with the quarry would generate noise and vibrations, which would affect both human health and the well-being of all animals. These disturbances could lead to long-term stress on individuals, particularly for families with young children, the elderly, and people with existing health conditions.
Traffic and Safety Concerns: The influx of heavy trucks and machinery, up to 500 trucks per day, required to transport materials from the quarry would significantly increase road traffic, posing safety risks and disrupting daily life for local residents. This increased traffic flow could also result in more frequent accidents and an overall deterioration in road conditions. The Monaro Highway is already a high risk road, especially during the snow season.
Property Values: The presence of a quarry will decrease property values in the surrounding areas, affecting homeowners. This loss in value will make it difficult for local families to maintain their homes and sell their property.
3. Health Risks for Immunocompromised and Vulnerable Individuals
The proposed Monaro Rock Quarry poses a serious public health risk, particularly to immunocompromised individuals and others with pre-existing medical conditions. These members of our community are especially vulnerable to environmental pollutants, and the introduction of large-scale quarry operations could significantly compromise their health and safety.
Airborne Particulates: Quarry operations produce fine particulate matter from blasting, crushing, and transportation of rock. These particles can be inhaled into the lungs and bloodstream, triggering severe respiratory issues. For immunocompromised people — including those undergoing cancer treatment, living with autoimmune diseases, organ transplant recipients, and others — this exposure can lead to chronic inflammation, infections, or hospitalization.
Increased Respiratory and Cardiovascular Risk: Quarry-related air pollution has been linked to exacerbated asthma, bronchitis, and cardiovascular issues — all of which pose a heightened danger to vulnerable individuals. The stress of chronic exposure to airborne pollutants can lower immune system effectiveness, leading to more frequent and severe illnesses.
Lack of Escape: Unlike healthy people who may tolerate or adapt to increased dust and pollution, immunocompromised people often do not have the option to safely remain in affected areas. This could force them to relocate, resulting in economic and emotional hardship.
Including vulnerable populations in planning and risk assessments is a legal and moral obligation. Proceeding with this quarry without adequately protecting the health of immunocompromised individuals would be a violation of public health responsibilities.
4. Community Opinion
With approximately 49000 people living within 10klm of the proposed site, and with the projected number around 69000 in the next 10 years, it is essential to recognise the voices of the community who have expressed opposition to this proposal. Local residents, businesses, and environmental advocates have raised significant concerns about the quarry’s potential effects. Ignoring the concerns of the people who live and work in the region would harm our community.
Conclusion
Given the significant environmental risks, adverse impacts on local communities, and the potential for long-term economic harm, I urge the relevant authorities to reject the proposal for the Monaro Rock Quarry. The preservation of our environment and community well-being, must take precedence over short-term industrial interests.
Thank you for considering this submission.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
ROYALLA
,
New South Wales
Message
To Whom It May Concern,
I would like to submit my strong opposition to the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site. This proposed development will have huge negative consequences for the local community of which I am a resident. It would also negatively impact the environment, and infrastructure.
Following are some of my concerns of the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site.
Air Pollution:
The quarry will introduce high levels of dust pollution to the surrounding area. This will impact the quality of life for residents. Dust emissions from the quarry would affect:
Air quality, leading to respiratory problems for my family who have auto immune diseases.
Contamination of house roof, from which our drinking water is collected.
Contamination of our vegetable gardens and fruit trees.
Contamination of our pastures which our livestock rely on.
Contamination will also negatively impacts the native flora and fauna.
Water use:
As the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site has no water supply so it will require to overuse of the underground water table which will change and damage the water table in the region.
Water run off will create environmental hazard for the native flora and fauna.
TrafficDanger:
As a First Responder with Fire and Rescue, I clearly know how dangerous the Monaro Highway and surrounding roads are and the large number of fatalities on the Monaro highway and road in the region. The significant increase in truck traffic on the Monaro Highway and local roads will increase existing traffic congestion and pose an increased danger to motorists. The roads in this area are not designed to accommodate the increased number of vehicle movements associated with quarry operations, which will lead to an increase risk of accidents.
Property Values:
The construction of the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site close to residential areas will lower the quality of life for local residents. The potential noise, dust, and traffic will make the area less desirable to live in, reducing property values. The financial and psychological toll of this outcome will lead to increased stress and health issues for families.
Proposed Location:
With other Quarry's in the region, another quarry is not required to supply materials. This is not a suitable location for a quarry development. The proposed location is close to existing residents and is not acceptable.
Thank you
I would like to submit my strong opposition to the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site. This proposed development will have huge negative consequences for the local community of which I am a resident. It would also negatively impact the environment, and infrastructure.
Following are some of my concerns of the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site.
Air Pollution:
The quarry will introduce high levels of dust pollution to the surrounding area. This will impact the quality of life for residents. Dust emissions from the quarry would affect:
Air quality, leading to respiratory problems for my family who have auto immune diseases.
Contamination of house roof, from which our drinking water is collected.
Contamination of our vegetable gardens and fruit trees.
Contamination of our pastures which our livestock rely on.
Contamination will also negatively impacts the native flora and fauna.
Water use:
As the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site has no water supply so it will require to overuse of the underground water table which will change and damage the water table in the region.
Water run off will create environmental hazard for the native flora and fauna.
TrafficDanger:
As a First Responder with Fire and Rescue, I clearly know how dangerous the Monaro Highway and surrounding roads are and the large number of fatalities on the Monaro highway and road in the region. The significant increase in truck traffic on the Monaro Highway and local roads will increase existing traffic congestion and pose an increased danger to motorists. The roads in this area are not designed to accommodate the increased number of vehicle movements associated with quarry operations, which will lead to an increase risk of accidents.
Property Values:
The construction of the proposed Monaro Rock Quarry Industrial site close to residential areas will lower the quality of life for local residents. The potential noise, dust, and traffic will make the area less desirable to live in, reducing property values. The financial and psychological toll of this outcome will lead to increased stress and health issues for families.
Proposed Location:
With other Quarry's in the region, another quarry is not required to supply materials. This is not a suitable location for a quarry development. The proposed location is close to existing residents and is not acceptable.
Thank you