Suzie Presswell
Object
Suzie Presswell
Object
MOSS VALE
,
New South Wales
Message
This development will increase the amount of heavy vehicles coming into our area - we are still a small country town and don't have the infrastructure to support what should be in a industrial area with the correct infrastructure.
The water and air quality will also be affected which is bad for health, enviornment and defeats the purpose of recycling when it causes so much damage to the environment.
I honestly do not want to be watching chimneys blowing out toxic waster from my residential street whilst we are breathing the toxic fumes.
The water and air quality will also be affected which is bad for health, enviornment and defeats the purpose of recycling when it causes so much damage to the environment.
I honestly do not want to be watching chimneys blowing out toxic waster from my residential street whilst we are breathing the toxic fumes.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
MOSS VALE
,
New South Wales
Message
My reasons for objecting to the recycling facility are:
o Research studies show local populations living close to these facilities suffer from serious health conditions, respiratory diseases, skin rashes and eye disorders, not to mention the potential cancers caused by plastic resin compounds.
o There is no doubt that this kind of waste industry is highly toxic to the local community and the environment due to Airborne Volatile Organic Compounds emitted during the process of turning plastic waste into flakes and pellets and products.
o Plasrefine Pty Ltd is a company registered in Australia, with 100% Chinese interests.
o The Factory is proposed to be located within 150m of homes.
o The site has 2 incompatible zones, Environmental Living and an under sized General Industrial portion.
o The site has highly sensitive environmental areas (Koala Habitat), and a category 2 riparian waterway that flows directly into the Wingecarribee River, the Drinking water Catchment!
o 5 acres (2 x 10,000sqms) of buildings in a highly visible area.
o Is close to 2 schools and an Early Childhood Centre.
o Proposed to function 24 hours a day 7 days a week.
o estimated 160-200 heavy vehicle truck movements and 280 light vehicle movements per day using the local residential Moss Vale road Network, (Light vehicles over 3 shifts in the 24 hour period).
o Trucks to deliver waste Mon-Fri 7am-6pm, causing more gridlock on our already choked roads.
o Proposed to take 120,000 tonne per year of dirty plastic waste from Sydney / Canberra / Wollongong.
o Wash / heat / shred / pellet and melt then make more plastic products, greenwashed by the term RECYCLING.
o Proposing to use 20,000L of our drinking water every day to wash plastic waste.
o Proposing to pump 10,000L of contaminated water into our already overloaded sewage system.
o Prevailing westerly winds will potentially blow smell and dust and Micro Plastics over Burradoo and Bowral.
o Will directly impact the highly sensitive Garvan site where a road extension will be forced.
o Will directly impact home prices in Moss Vale.
o Research studies show local populations living close to these facilities suffer from serious health conditions, respiratory diseases, skin rashes and eye disorders, not to mention the potential cancers caused by plastic resin compounds.
o There is no doubt that this kind of waste industry is highly toxic to the local community and the environment due to Airborne Volatile Organic Compounds emitted during the process of turning plastic waste into flakes and pellets and products.
o Plasrefine Pty Ltd is a company registered in Australia, with 100% Chinese interests.
o The Factory is proposed to be located within 150m of homes.
o The site has 2 incompatible zones, Environmental Living and an under sized General Industrial portion.
o The site has highly sensitive environmental areas (Koala Habitat), and a category 2 riparian waterway that flows directly into the Wingecarribee River, the Drinking water Catchment!
o 5 acres (2 x 10,000sqms) of buildings in a highly visible area.
o Is close to 2 schools and an Early Childhood Centre.
o Proposed to function 24 hours a day 7 days a week.
o estimated 160-200 heavy vehicle truck movements and 280 light vehicle movements per day using the local residential Moss Vale road Network, (Light vehicles over 3 shifts in the 24 hour period).
o Trucks to deliver waste Mon-Fri 7am-6pm, causing more gridlock on our already choked roads.
o Proposed to take 120,000 tonne per year of dirty plastic waste from Sydney / Canberra / Wollongong.
o Wash / heat / shred / pellet and melt then make more plastic products, greenwashed by the term RECYCLING.
o Proposing to use 20,000L of our drinking water every day to wash plastic waste.
o Proposing to pump 10,000L of contaminated water into our already overloaded sewage system.
o Prevailing westerly winds will potentially blow smell and dust and Micro Plastics over Burradoo and Bowral.
o Will directly impact the highly sensitive Garvan site where a road extension will be forced.
o Will directly impact home prices in Moss Vale.
Danuta Hulajko
Object
Danuta Hulajko
Object
MOSS VALE
,
New South Wales
Message
I Danuta Hulajko, resident of Moss Vale object to the proposed development SSD—9409987
2.1 Does SEPP 33 Apply? (Hazardous and Offensive Development Application Guidelines Applying SEPP 33)
This section provides advice to consent authorities on deciding whether SEPP 33 applies to a proposal and how to apply the new definitions the policy introduces. Consent authorities should firstly consider whether the proposed use falls within the definition of ‘industry’ adopted by the planning instrument which applies or whether it is a ‘storage establishment’. Once a proposal is identified as an industry or storage establishment, consent authorities need to consider: • Does the proposal require development consent or approval under Part 3A or Part 4 of the EP&A Act? • Is the proposal ‘potentially hazardous industry’? • Is the proposal ‘potentially offensive industry’? Note: For the purposes of SEPP 33, a hazardous storage establishment is included in the definition of potentially hazardous industry. Similarly, an offensive storage establishment is included in the definition of potentially offensive industry. This means that a storage development is considered ‘industry’ for the purposes of applying the SEPP 33 tests, even if the development is non-industrial. An example may be a storage facility associated with the reticulation of LPG within a housing development. SEPP 33 will apply if a proposal for an industrial development requires consent, and it is either potentially hazardous industry or potentially offensive industry (or both). Figure 1 indicates the procedure for determining if SEPP 33 applies, while Figure 2 outlines the associated assessment process for a typical Part 4 local development. Question 2.1 what supporting information should I seek in order to determined
Base on the requirements of the SEPP 33 the proposed development is potentially hazardous in nature as it involves plastics and polymers for reprocessing. While the plastic products prior to recycling or final products may not be hazardous and toxic there are some stages in the reprocessing of each of those plastics are hazardous and toxic as discussed below.
Section 7.5.1 of the EIS
This section lists 6 types of plastics and polymers which will be crushed ( powder will be in the) , melted at a high temperature and molded into new plastic products. I cannot find anywhere in the EIS how the proponent is going to address this. The Material Safety Data Sheet (MSD) for each of those plastic is discussed below. Two of plastic proposed for recycling are potentially explosive in the powder form. Other byproducts like plastic sludge is deadly to the enviromement ( water, wildlife, humans , soil) and cannot be disposed just anywhere like in Bowral waste facility as GHD report suggests. The GHD Project Manager David Gamble could not answer any of my questions nor the Director of Plasrefine, Nanxi Zheng from China present at last week meeting with the community in Exeter.
To my knowledge Mrs. Zheng and her uncle in China (investor) do not have the expertise in plastic recycling at all.
Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) Bottles
Hazards of this product may be associated with its processing: spilled pellets create a slipping hazard. Molten plastic can cause severe thermal burns. Fumes produced during the thermal processing of polymer melt may cause eye, skin and respiratory tract irritation. Treat in the same way as other thermal burns and wood smoke inhalation.
https://www.polisanhellas.com/pdf/Doc_PetResins_MSDS_PoliPET_PolisanHellas_2017.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3LApoJLLjZYZX7zxB53GS-uSB2XD-Lss-4hq_T0XPPxm-26IEjdGcCbMY
High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) bottles
High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) In case of fire – • Extinguishing Media: Extinguish preferably with foam, carbon dioxide or dry chemical. • Fire Fighting Protective Equipment: A self-contained breathing apparatus and suitable protective clothing should be worn in fire conditions. • Hazardous Decomposition Product(s): Combustion or thermal decomposition will evolve irritant vapours. • Can melt and burn in a fire. Molten material tends to flow or drip and will propagate fire. See Physical Hazard Information. For more information, request the relevant Material Data Safety Sheet from RIL
That is very reassuring: “propagates fire...”
https://www.ril.com/DownloadFiles/Polymers/assessment/pra_relene_pe_hdp.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1SYiJSCl4SmPMO_Id5QOG4gvBSJ16Oj4nU3Jr8ZLrNFiNJPwIB8EEeuWY
Polypropylene (PP)
PP bottles, this is a real gem" Dust may form explosive mixtures with air"
Will accumulates static charges that may cause an electric spark (ignition source). and more horror precautions. You need to read it yourself. Sort of like dynamite to me.
“6.2 Environmental precautions
Gather pellets and powder thoroughly to avoid birds or fishes taking from draining water. Do not allow product to reach sewage system or water bodies. Inform respective authorities in case product reaches water, sewage system or soil
General information: Do not allow to enter into ground-water, surface water or drains.
Measures to prevent fire: Prevent from fire around handling area Measures to prevent aerosol and dust generation: maintain good housekeeping standards to prevent accumulation of dust. To avoid dust explosion resulting from the existence of powder, electrostatics eliminators and grounding should be fixed to such equipment as air transferring pipes, bag filters and hoppers. Use electrically conductive filters for bag filters”
Toxicological effects: - Acute toxicity (oral): Lack of data. - Acute toxicity (dermal): Lack of data. - Acute toxicity (inhalative): Lack of data. - Skin corrosion/irritation: Lack of data. May cause irritations
Eye damage/irritation: Lack of data. May cause irritations. - Sensitisation to the respiratory tract: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Skin sensitisation: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Germ cell mutagenicity/Genotoxicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Carcinogenicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Reproductive toxicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Effects on or via lactation: Lack of data. - Specific target organ toxicity (single exposure): Lack of data. - Dusts: Irritating to eyes, respiratory system and skin. - Specific target organ toxicity (repeated exposure): Lack of data.
Other information Styrene: - Harmful if inhaled. Causes damage to organs through prolonged or repeated exposure. - lung damages - May be fatal if swallowed and enters airways. - Causes serious eye irritation. Causes skin irritation. Acrylonitrile: - Toxic by inhalation, in contact with skin and if swallowed. - May cause cancer. Suspected of damaging the unborn child. - Causes skin irritation. May cause an allergic skin reaction. Causes serious eye - damage. 1,3-Butadiene: - May cause cancer. May cause genetic defects. Symptoms - Dust:Can cause skin, eye and respiratory tract irritation. - The melted product can cause severe burns. - Thermal treatment, Processing: - Irritating to eyes, respiratory system and skin. - In case of ingestion: Swallowing may cause gastrointestinal irritation and pain of guts.
12.3 Bioaccumulative potential To avoid bioaccumulation plastics should not be disposed in the sea or in other water environments.
12.5 Other adverse effects: General information: Do not allow to enter into ground-water, surface water or drains.
Low density polyethylene (LDPE) films
HAZARDOUS PRODUCTS OF COMBUSTION: Carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and aldehydes
Exposure to CO2 can produce a variety of health effects. These may include headaches, dizziness, restlessness, a tingling or pins or needles feeling, difficulty breathing, sweating, tiredness, increased heart rate, elevated blood pressure, coma, asphyxia, and convulsions.
Carbon monoxide poisoning occurs when carbon monoxide builds up in your bloodstream. When too much carbon monoxide is in the air, your body replaces the oxygen in your red blood cells with carbon monoxide. This can lead to serious tissue damage, or even death.
Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, tasteless gas produced by burning gasoline, wood, propane, charcoal or other fuel. Improperly ventilated appliances and engines, particularly in a tightly sealed or enclosed space, may allow carbon monoxide to accumulate to dangerous levels.
Uplasticized polyvibyl chloride (UPVC) pipes
Environmental precautions: Cautions should be exerted not to affect the environment resulting from release to rivers etc. Never discharge to the environment.
Melting point Softens at >75 0 C.
Fire Incompatibility Oxidising agents. Hydrogen peroxide, ozone, oxygen, potassium nitrate, and nitric acid are all oxidizing agents. All of the halogens are oxidizing agents (e.g., chlorine, bromine, fluorine Oxidizer as a Dangerous Material
Because an oxidizer may contribute to combustion, it may be classified as a dangerous material. The hazard symbol for an oxidizer is a circle with flames on top of it.
Storage Store in appropriate areas (outside or in warehouse) in accordance with site safety requirements. Do not store with oxidising agents.
https://www.redwoodplastics.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/LDPE-2012.pdf
LEP 2010 and the Proposed Southern Highlands Innovation Park DCP
The subject land and the adjoining land has been rezoned in 1981 from Rural to General Industrial. Since then the Wingecarribbe Council has not prepared a draft of this DCPP Plasrefine is potentially toxic and hazardous industry there not General Industry under the definition of the Wingecarribee Council LEP 2010. If approved it will generate a precedence of heavy /hazardous industry immediately adjacent to residential (R2) and Enviromental Living(E4) Primary Production Small Lots ( RU4).
Therefore the proposed development is incompatible with the adjacent zoning and land use.
2.1 Does SEPP 33 Apply? (Hazardous and Offensive Development Application Guidelines Applying SEPP 33)
This section provides advice to consent authorities on deciding whether SEPP 33 applies to a proposal and how to apply the new definitions the policy introduces. Consent authorities should firstly consider whether the proposed use falls within the definition of ‘industry’ adopted by the planning instrument which applies or whether it is a ‘storage establishment’. Once a proposal is identified as an industry or storage establishment, consent authorities need to consider: • Does the proposal require development consent or approval under Part 3A or Part 4 of the EP&A Act? • Is the proposal ‘potentially hazardous industry’? • Is the proposal ‘potentially offensive industry’? Note: For the purposes of SEPP 33, a hazardous storage establishment is included in the definition of potentially hazardous industry. Similarly, an offensive storage establishment is included in the definition of potentially offensive industry. This means that a storage development is considered ‘industry’ for the purposes of applying the SEPP 33 tests, even if the development is non-industrial. An example may be a storage facility associated with the reticulation of LPG within a housing development. SEPP 33 will apply if a proposal for an industrial development requires consent, and it is either potentially hazardous industry or potentially offensive industry (or both). Figure 1 indicates the procedure for determining if SEPP 33 applies, while Figure 2 outlines the associated assessment process for a typical Part 4 local development. Question 2.1 what supporting information should I seek in order to determined
Base on the requirements of the SEPP 33 the proposed development is potentially hazardous in nature as it involves plastics and polymers for reprocessing. While the plastic products prior to recycling or final products may not be hazardous and toxic there are some stages in the reprocessing of each of those plastics are hazardous and toxic as discussed below.
Section 7.5.1 of the EIS
This section lists 6 types of plastics and polymers which will be crushed ( powder will be in the) , melted at a high temperature and molded into new plastic products. I cannot find anywhere in the EIS how the proponent is going to address this. The Material Safety Data Sheet (MSD) for each of those plastic is discussed below. Two of plastic proposed for recycling are potentially explosive in the powder form. Other byproducts like plastic sludge is deadly to the enviromement ( water, wildlife, humans , soil) and cannot be disposed just anywhere like in Bowral waste facility as GHD report suggests. The GHD Project Manager David Gamble could not answer any of my questions nor the Director of Plasrefine, Nanxi Zheng from China present at last week meeting with the community in Exeter.
To my knowledge Mrs. Zheng and her uncle in China (investor) do not have the expertise in plastic recycling at all.
Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) Bottles
Hazards of this product may be associated with its processing: spilled pellets create a slipping hazard. Molten plastic can cause severe thermal burns. Fumes produced during the thermal processing of polymer melt may cause eye, skin and respiratory tract irritation. Treat in the same way as other thermal burns and wood smoke inhalation.
https://www.polisanhellas.com/pdf/Doc_PetResins_MSDS_PoliPET_PolisanHellas_2017.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3LApoJLLjZYZX7zxB53GS-uSB2XD-Lss-4hq_T0XPPxm-26IEjdGcCbMY
High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) bottles
High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) In case of fire – • Extinguishing Media: Extinguish preferably with foam, carbon dioxide or dry chemical. • Fire Fighting Protective Equipment: A self-contained breathing apparatus and suitable protective clothing should be worn in fire conditions. • Hazardous Decomposition Product(s): Combustion or thermal decomposition will evolve irritant vapours. • Can melt and burn in a fire. Molten material tends to flow or drip and will propagate fire. See Physical Hazard Information. For more information, request the relevant Material Data Safety Sheet from RIL
That is very reassuring: “propagates fire...”
https://www.ril.com/DownloadFiles/Polymers/assessment/pra_relene_pe_hdp.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1SYiJSCl4SmPMO_Id5QOG4gvBSJ16Oj4nU3Jr8ZLrNFiNJPwIB8EEeuWY
Polypropylene (PP)
PP bottles, this is a real gem" Dust may form explosive mixtures with air"
Will accumulates static charges that may cause an electric spark (ignition source). and more horror precautions. You need to read it yourself. Sort of like dynamite to me.
“6.2 Environmental precautions
Gather pellets and powder thoroughly to avoid birds or fishes taking from draining water. Do not allow product to reach sewage system or water bodies. Inform respective authorities in case product reaches water, sewage system or soil
General information: Do not allow to enter into ground-water, surface water or drains.
Measures to prevent fire: Prevent from fire around handling area Measures to prevent aerosol and dust generation: maintain good housekeeping standards to prevent accumulation of dust. To avoid dust explosion resulting from the existence of powder, electrostatics eliminators and grounding should be fixed to such equipment as air transferring pipes, bag filters and hoppers. Use electrically conductive filters for bag filters”
Toxicological effects: - Acute toxicity (oral): Lack of data. - Acute toxicity (dermal): Lack of data. - Acute toxicity (inhalative): Lack of data. - Skin corrosion/irritation: Lack of data. May cause irritations
Eye damage/irritation: Lack of data. May cause irritations. - Sensitisation to the respiratory tract: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Skin sensitisation: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Germ cell mutagenicity/Genotoxicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Carcinogenicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Reproductive toxicity: Lack of data. Not to be expected - Effects on or via lactation: Lack of data. - Specific target organ toxicity (single exposure): Lack of data. - Dusts: Irritating to eyes, respiratory system and skin. - Specific target organ toxicity (repeated exposure): Lack of data.
Other information Styrene: - Harmful if inhaled. Causes damage to organs through prolonged or repeated exposure. - lung damages - May be fatal if swallowed and enters airways. - Causes serious eye irritation. Causes skin irritation. Acrylonitrile: - Toxic by inhalation, in contact with skin and if swallowed. - May cause cancer. Suspected of damaging the unborn child. - Causes skin irritation. May cause an allergic skin reaction. Causes serious eye - damage. 1,3-Butadiene: - May cause cancer. May cause genetic defects. Symptoms - Dust:Can cause skin, eye and respiratory tract irritation. - The melted product can cause severe burns. - Thermal treatment, Processing: - Irritating to eyes, respiratory system and skin. - In case of ingestion: Swallowing may cause gastrointestinal irritation and pain of guts.
12.3 Bioaccumulative potential To avoid bioaccumulation plastics should not be disposed in the sea or in other water environments.
12.5 Other adverse effects: General information: Do not allow to enter into ground-water, surface water or drains.
Low density polyethylene (LDPE) films
HAZARDOUS PRODUCTS OF COMBUSTION: Carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and aldehydes
Exposure to CO2 can produce a variety of health effects. These may include headaches, dizziness, restlessness, a tingling or pins or needles feeling, difficulty breathing, sweating, tiredness, increased heart rate, elevated blood pressure, coma, asphyxia, and convulsions.
Carbon monoxide poisoning occurs when carbon monoxide builds up in your bloodstream. When too much carbon monoxide is in the air, your body replaces the oxygen in your red blood cells with carbon monoxide. This can lead to serious tissue damage, or even death.
Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, tasteless gas produced by burning gasoline, wood, propane, charcoal or other fuel. Improperly ventilated appliances and engines, particularly in a tightly sealed or enclosed space, may allow carbon monoxide to accumulate to dangerous levels.
Uplasticized polyvibyl chloride (UPVC) pipes
Environmental precautions: Cautions should be exerted not to affect the environment resulting from release to rivers etc. Never discharge to the environment.
Melting point Softens at >75 0 C.
Fire Incompatibility Oxidising agents. Hydrogen peroxide, ozone, oxygen, potassium nitrate, and nitric acid are all oxidizing agents. All of the halogens are oxidizing agents (e.g., chlorine, bromine, fluorine Oxidizer as a Dangerous Material
Because an oxidizer may contribute to combustion, it may be classified as a dangerous material. The hazard symbol for an oxidizer is a circle with flames on top of it.
Storage Store in appropriate areas (outside or in warehouse) in accordance with site safety requirements. Do not store with oxidising agents.
https://www.redwoodplastics.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/LDPE-2012.pdf
LEP 2010 and the Proposed Southern Highlands Innovation Park DCP
The subject land and the adjoining land has been rezoned in 1981 from Rural to General Industrial. Since then the Wingecarribbe Council has not prepared a draft of this DCPP Plasrefine is potentially toxic and hazardous industry there not General Industry under the definition of the Wingecarribee Council LEP 2010. If approved it will generate a precedence of heavy /hazardous industry immediately adjacent to residential (R2) and Enviromental Living(E4) Primary Production Small Lots ( RU4).
Therefore the proposed development is incompatible with the adjacent zoning and land use.
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
MOSS VALE
,
New South Wales
Message
Please see attached letter in objection to the proposed Plasrefine Facility at Moss Vale.
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
MOSS VALE
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the project. Please see attached letter for details.
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
BOWRAL
,
New South Wales
Message
As a rural community, Moss Vale and Bowral are small communities which are surrounded by rural pastureland. The relatively small population are mostly sustained by rural projects and people who have moved here for peace, solitude and the quiet rural life. There are also areas of protected natural forest in the area (the Southern Highlands Shale Forest and Woodland) which are very fragile and need to be sustained. The roads in the area are NOT suitable for large amounts of traffic. Tourism is another of the most viable financial intakes in the area and NO-ONE coming to the area wants to be confronted by the heavy truck traffic, odours and environmental destruction caused by this project, let alone the local population who DO NOT want heavy traffic, nor the smells and industrial outlook, for which reason I left the city in the first place. This environment is extremely fragile I am vehemently OPPOSED to this development in every way.
Name Withheld
Support
Name Withheld
Support
ZETLAND
,
New South Wales
Message
I like this project, it is very good for the enviroment.
I hope everyone supports this project, without this factory, more and more plastic waste will go to landfill.
We should use less plastic and use more recyclable things, keep a low carbon life style.
I hope everyone supports this project, without this factory, more and more plastic waste will go to landfill.
We should use less plastic and use more recyclable things, keep a low carbon life style.