Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Ourimbah
,
New South Wales
Message
At what point will this need for greed cease? Lining the pockets of already sickeningly wealthy organisations at the cost of our environment disgusts me beyond belief. It's about time you STOPPED MINING & DESTROYING OUR LANDS before it's too late to save our precious environment. Here's a thought...try making money without raping our land!!!!
Name Withheld
Support
Name Withheld
Support
Kandos
,
New South Wales
Message
I write this submission in support of the Bylong Coal Project, yes while I understand there are environmental issues to be dealt with, and I am sure that the company will adhere to all or any conditions placed on them, the approval and go ahead of this project is vital to keep this area alive. Kandos and Rylstone, especially Kandos are two small towns doing it very tough at the moment following the closure of Cement Australia's Kandos Plant in 2011, the closure of Charbon underground mine and washery, and very recently the closure and liquidation of Big Rim open cut coal mine leaving its employees with virtually nothing, the job losses from all of the above have had a huge impact on the town, and have a huge flow on effect with families leaving the area, taking children from schools, then hence schools cut staff, vital services cut staff, local businesses suffer, from everything from the sale of newspapers and magazines, to food and fuel. A project like this might give a glimmer of hope to the survival of Kandos, and some encouragement to keep the next generation of workers (students leaving yrs 11 & 12) that there may be a job for them locally, and not have to leave the area and leave families, but not only these young people, but maybe provide some employment for those who have just lost jobs. While we realise that if approved, jobs etc won't happen overnight, at least it might encourage people to stay in the area and put some positive light back in the towns.
I am sure there are plenty of objectors to this project, but are they the ones suffering from recent jobs lost, small business trying to keep their head above water, families trying to stay in town and support it where they can, are they going to provide jobs for the next generation of young people looking for work, I'm guessing not. This mine isn't even in operation yet, but already they provide community funding and donations to local charities and projects.
I could keep writing forever, but the main aim of my submission, is of support for this mine and hope that approval can be granted and some spirit put back into the local area.
Thank you, and look forward to hopefully reading, hearing about this mine's approval in the near future.
I request please, that my name and address details are withheld from publication.
I am sure there are plenty of objectors to this project, but are they the ones suffering from recent jobs lost, small business trying to keep their head above water, families trying to stay in town and support it where they can, are they going to provide jobs for the next generation of young people looking for work, I'm guessing not. This mine isn't even in operation yet, but already they provide community funding and donations to local charities and projects.
I could keep writing forever, but the main aim of my submission, is of support for this mine and hope that approval can be granted and some spirit put back into the local area.
Thank you, and look forward to hopefully reading, hearing about this mine's approval in the near future.
I request please, that my name and address details are withheld from publication.
Marie Mitchell
Object
Marie Mitchell
Object
Bulga
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the proposed Bylong Coal Project (SSD 14_6367) by Korean power company Kepco.
To allow this foreign owned company to proceed with this project is ludicrous.
It will destroy 2,875ha of prime agricultural land including Tarwyn Park, a successful natural sequence farm and 700ha of Critical Equine Industry Cluster.
By allowing this mine to use 75% of the annual rainfall will cause local farmers to lose water supply from an already stressed catchment.
The risk of losing another 144 Aboriginal culturally significant sites will add to the desiccation which has already occurred on many other mine sites and shows a lack of respect for the Aboriginal Community.
Proposed off-sets will in no way mitigate the effects on endangered flora and fauna.
The effects on historical European heritage in the Bylong area would be disastrous and unacceptable.
The once beautiful Hunter Valley has been destroyed by open-cut coal mining. Don't sacrifice another pristine valley for foreign profit.
This project must not be approved.
To allow this foreign owned company to proceed with this project is ludicrous.
It will destroy 2,875ha of prime agricultural land including Tarwyn Park, a successful natural sequence farm and 700ha of Critical Equine Industry Cluster.
By allowing this mine to use 75% of the annual rainfall will cause local farmers to lose water supply from an already stressed catchment.
The risk of losing another 144 Aboriginal culturally significant sites will add to the desiccation which has already occurred on many other mine sites and shows a lack of respect for the Aboriginal Community.
Proposed off-sets will in no way mitigate the effects on endangered flora and fauna.
The effects on historical European heritage in the Bylong area would be disastrous and unacceptable.
The once beautiful Hunter Valley has been destroyed by open-cut coal mining. Don't sacrifice another pristine valley for foreign profit.
This project must not be approved.
Stephen Spencer
Object
Stephen Spencer
Object
Cooks Hill
,
New South Wales
Message
The Bylong Valley drive is one of the most beautiful in the country, I'm proud to bring overseas visitors to it and it would be a shame to lose it. It is bad enough around Warkworth, but to extend it to an area of such beauty is very disappointing.
Schmidt Alison
Object
Schmidt Alison
Object
Wollar
,
New South Wales
Message
I wish to object to the current proposal of coal mining in the highly fertile bylong valley. When 75% of rainfall recharge water to the river system is used by one company local farmers will lose crucial water supply.
The accumulative affects of yet another mine in the region have not been addressed.
There is no assessment of increased traffic through Wollar or on the Mudgee to Wollar rd.
Increased train movements will not only add to the pollution in Wollar but all the way to port as they wait in loops and add to the train jam spewing diesel fumes. Yet more maintenance of rail will see more 24hr machinery along the line and roads.
The social impacts and loss of services in both Wollar and Bylong are already devasting. This proposal will take that to another level, including totally stranded assets.
The accumulative affects of yet another mine in the region have not been addressed.
There is no assessment of increased traffic through Wollar or on the Mudgee to Wollar rd.
Increased train movements will not only add to the pollution in Wollar but all the way to port as they wait in loops and add to the train jam spewing diesel fumes. Yet more maintenance of rail will see more 24hr machinery along the line and roads.
The social impacts and loss of services in both Wollar and Bylong are already devasting. This proposal will take that to another level, including totally stranded assets.
Jessica Weaver
Comment
Jessica Weaver
Comment
Strathfield
,
New South Wales
Message
I am an early childhood educator. Part of our early childhood curriculum is to teach sustainable practices, to reduce our ecological footprint and encourage younger generations to care for our world. However, the damage that is done through the process of mining is somewhat irreversible. The fossil fuels which we mine are created over hundreds of millions of years and yet, we destroy them within a matter of minutes - not the mention the damage we do in the process to the land from which they are derived.
Coal may be a major export from Australia, but so is our food. This prime agricultural land will be destroyed and forever changed through the process of mining. If we take away the land, where do you expect we will produce the quality food which is also a major export? In addition to this, the surrounding farm land which is already affected by drought will be increasingly effected by the lack of water as the mining process sucks the land dry, releasing toxic chemicals into the land, water supply and air. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that we are destroying the atmosphere, killing the land and animals and in essence, destroying ourselves and the future of humanity as individuals (such as those supporting the mines) continue to make conscious choices and educated decisions with a focus on money, rather than the well-being of the future.
Coal may be a major export from Australia, but so is our food. This prime agricultural land will be destroyed and forever changed through the process of mining. If we take away the land, where do you expect we will produce the quality food which is also a major export? In addition to this, the surrounding farm land which is already affected by drought will be increasingly effected by the lack of water as the mining process sucks the land dry, releasing toxic chemicals into the land, water supply and air. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that we are destroying the atmosphere, killing the land and animals and in essence, destroying ourselves and the future of humanity as individuals (such as those supporting the mines) continue to make conscious choices and educated decisions with a focus on money, rather than the well-being of the future.
Ruth Boydell
Object
Ruth Boydell
Object
Garden Suburb
,
New South Wales
Message
Please keep this village in its pristine form.
Please do not allow coal mining in this town region.
Please do not allow coal mining in this town region.
Denise McGarry
Object
Denise McGarry
Object
Marsfield
,
New South Wales
Message
Please do not allow mining in the Bylong Valley. It is an area of high natural beauty and significant agricultural value. These will both be irretrievably lost for short-term non-renewal gain.
Christopher Smith
Support
Christopher Smith
Support
SINGLETON
,
New South Wales
Message
As a professional mining engineer and concerned resident of NSW, I am writing to you in strong support of the Bylong Coal Project.
I have a good understanding of the geology and economics of the Bylong Valley thermal coal deposit and it warrants development to continue to meet the demand for high quality thermal in Korea and south east Asia. Kepco has invested wisely and generously in the Bylong Valley to develop this state owned asset and has committed to developing the operation in accordance with the strict environmental controls in place in NSW.
For the state of NSW to continue to grow and develop infrastructure there is a need for governments to promote and nurture industries which generate significant revenue streams for government and provide employment opportunities for its peoples. The Hunter Valley coal industry has done this admirably for decades and hopefully will be allowed to continue to do so in the adjacent Bylong Valley with product coal hauled to the Port of Newcastle along the existing railway line.
I am a long term Singleton resident and a father of 3 and am gravely concerned that the employment prospects I enjoyed as a young engineer will become non existent due to the current planning approval process.
I urge you to examine and weigh up the strong economic and community benefits of the project and ensure that controls are in place to safeguard the environment. This can be achieved through an appropriate assessment report that will support a Project Approval by the Minister for Planning or their delegate for the Bylong Coal Project
I have a good understanding of the geology and economics of the Bylong Valley thermal coal deposit and it warrants development to continue to meet the demand for high quality thermal in Korea and south east Asia. Kepco has invested wisely and generously in the Bylong Valley to develop this state owned asset and has committed to developing the operation in accordance with the strict environmental controls in place in NSW.
For the state of NSW to continue to grow and develop infrastructure there is a need for governments to promote and nurture industries which generate significant revenue streams for government and provide employment opportunities for its peoples. The Hunter Valley coal industry has done this admirably for decades and hopefully will be allowed to continue to do so in the adjacent Bylong Valley with product coal hauled to the Port of Newcastle along the existing railway line.
I am a long term Singleton resident and a father of 3 and am gravely concerned that the employment prospects I enjoyed as a young engineer will become non existent due to the current planning approval process.
I urge you to examine and weigh up the strong economic and community benefits of the project and ensure that controls are in place to safeguard the environment. This can be achieved through an appropriate assessment report that will support a Project Approval by the Minister for Planning or their delegate for the Bylong Coal Project
Corey Willis
Object
Corey Willis
Object
Meadowbank
,
New South Wales
Message
1. The predicted long-term impacts on prime agricultural land and water systems in the Bylong Valley are unacceptable and will not be mitigated through proposed offsets and rehabilitation. The renowned Tarwyn Park natural sequence farming processes will be destroyed.
2. A significant area of prime agricultural land will be destroyed: the mine footprint will disturb 2,875 hectares (ha) of land including 440 ha of Bioregional Significant Agricultural Land (BSAL), 260 ha being destroyed in open cut, plus 700 ha of mapped Critical Equine Industry Cluster land. The proposal to replace BSAL at another location is untested and high risk.
3. Impacts on groundwater and surface water will be significant. The highly connected alluvial aquifer system within the stressed Bylong River catchment will have predicted peak losses of up to 295 million litres per year (ML/yr). Loss of base flows to the Bylong River is predicted to be 918 ML/yr. The mine proposes to use up to 1,942 ML/yr which is over 75% of the annual rainfall recharge. The river system is over allocated and local farmers will lose important water supply.
4. The mine disturbance area has very high biodiversity values that will not be mitigated through the proposed offset arrangements. Nationally endangered species recorded in the area include the Brush-tailed Rock Wallaby, New Holland Mouse, Regent Honeyeater and Spotted-tailed Quoll. Three entirely new plant species were recorded. A significant area of critically endangered Grassy Box Gum Woodland will be destroyed along with habitat for 17 threatened birds and 7 threatened plants.
5. The area has Aboriginal cultural heritage significance: 239 sites were recorded in the study area with 25 regarded as being of high local or regional significance (including an ochre quarry, grinding grooves and rock shelters); 144 sites have been identified at risk from mine impacts with 102 within the open cut area.
6. Important European heritage, including the Catholic Church Cemetery, Upper Bylong Public School and a number of historic homesteads and farm buildings will be destroyed in the open-cut. The social impacts on the Bylong community have already been devastating.
2. A significant area of prime agricultural land will be destroyed: the mine footprint will disturb 2,875 hectares (ha) of land including 440 ha of Bioregional Significant Agricultural Land (BSAL), 260 ha being destroyed in open cut, plus 700 ha of mapped Critical Equine Industry Cluster land. The proposal to replace BSAL at another location is untested and high risk.
3. Impacts on groundwater and surface water will be significant. The highly connected alluvial aquifer system within the stressed Bylong River catchment will have predicted peak losses of up to 295 million litres per year (ML/yr). Loss of base flows to the Bylong River is predicted to be 918 ML/yr. The mine proposes to use up to 1,942 ML/yr which is over 75% of the annual rainfall recharge. The river system is over allocated and local farmers will lose important water supply.
4. The mine disturbance area has very high biodiversity values that will not be mitigated through the proposed offset arrangements. Nationally endangered species recorded in the area include the Brush-tailed Rock Wallaby, New Holland Mouse, Regent Honeyeater and Spotted-tailed Quoll. Three entirely new plant species were recorded. A significant area of critically endangered Grassy Box Gum Woodland will be destroyed along with habitat for 17 threatened birds and 7 threatened plants.
5. The area has Aboriginal cultural heritage significance: 239 sites were recorded in the study area with 25 regarded as being of high local or regional significance (including an ochre quarry, grinding grooves and rock shelters); 144 sites have been identified at risk from mine impacts with 102 within the open cut area.
6. Important European heritage, including the Catholic Church Cemetery, Upper Bylong Public School and a number of historic homesteads and farm buildings will be destroyed in the open-cut. The social impacts on the Bylong community have already been devastating.