Current Status: Determination
Interact with the stages for their names
- SEARs
- Prepare Mod Report
- Exhibition
- Collate Submissions
- Assessment
- Recommendation
- Determination
Attachments & Resources
Application (3)
Submissions (3)
Response to Submissions (1)
Recommendation (1)
Determination (2)
Submissions
Showing 1 - 4 of 4 submissions
Barbara Davis
Object
Barbara Davis
Object
Cheltenham
,
New South Wales
Message
This modification proposes a temporary increase in road haulage of coal from 3.5Mt to 4Mt per annum.
Any increase in coal mining operations including transportation is at odds with Australia's 2015 commitment at Paris to reduce CO2 emissions. Burning coal is incompatible with efforts to keep global temperature rise under 1.5 degrees.
Mining and transporting coal enables burning of coal and is likewise incompatible with this goal.
Current policies are not working to reduce Australia's greenhouse gas equivalents which are rising again (National Greenhouse Gas Inventory Dec 2015). Australia needs to be serious about reducing not increasing coal production for combustion here and elsewhere through its exports.
Whitehaven's justification that
"The increased haulage rate is required due to favourable mining conditions which are allowing increased coal recovery without material changes to other approved operations such as the mining rate, operating hours or number of employees"
does not consider the negative impacts of this continued activity on "the atmospheric conditions" (global warming) which affect us all.
In addition there will be adverse local effects for the community from 88 additional truck haulages per day due to extra noise and pollution and the potential for more road accidents.
"Favourable mining conditions" are no longer a satisfactory justification for coal projects ( all of which are jeopardise climate and local amenity).
Any increase in coal mining operations including transportation is at odds with Australia's 2015 commitment at Paris to reduce CO2 emissions. Burning coal is incompatible with efforts to keep global temperature rise under 1.5 degrees.
Mining and transporting coal enables burning of coal and is likewise incompatible with this goal.
Current policies are not working to reduce Australia's greenhouse gas equivalents which are rising again (National Greenhouse Gas Inventory Dec 2015). Australia needs to be serious about reducing not increasing coal production for combustion here and elsewhere through its exports.
Whitehaven's justification that
"The increased haulage rate is required due to favourable mining conditions which are allowing increased coal recovery without material changes to other approved operations such as the mining rate, operating hours or number of employees"
does not consider the negative impacts of this continued activity on "the atmospheric conditions" (global warming) which affect us all.
In addition there will be adverse local effects for the community from 88 additional truck haulages per day due to extra noise and pollution and the potential for more road accidents.
"Favourable mining conditions" are no longer a satisfactory justification for coal projects ( all of which are jeopardise climate and local amenity).
Narrabri Shire Council
Comment
Narrabri Shire Council
Comment
Gunnedhan Shire Council
Comment
Gunnedhan Shire Council
Comment
Roads and Maritime Service
Comment
Roads and Maritime Service
Comment
Pagination
Project Details
Application Number
MP10_0015-Mod-3
Main Project
MP10_0015
Assessment Type
SSD Modifications
Development Type
Coal Mining
Local Government Areas
Gunnedah Shire
Decision
Approved
Determination Date
Decider
ED
Contact Planner
Name
To be
assigned
Related Projects
MP10_0015-Mod-1
Determination
SSD Modifications
Mod 1 - Coal Haulage
Wean Road Gunnedah New South Wales Australia 2380
MP10_0015-Mod-2
Determination
SSD Modifications
Mod 2 - Rejects Management
Wean Road Gunnedah New South Wales Australia 2380
MP10_0015-Mod-3
Determination
SSD Modifications
Mod 3
Wean Road Gunnedah New South Wales Australia 2380
MP10_0015-Mod-4
Determination
SSD Modifications
Mod 4
Wean Road Gunnedah New South Wales Australia 2380