State Significant Development
Determination
Forensic Pathology and Coroner's Court
Cumberland
Current Status: Determination
Interact with the stages for their names
- SEARs
- Prepare EIS
- Exhibition
- Collate Submissions
- Response to Submissions
- Assessment
- Recommendation
- Determination
Attachments & Resources
Application (2)
Request for SEARs (2)
SEARS (1)
EIS (37)
Submissions (4)
Response to Submissions (11)
Determination (4)
Approved Documents
There are no post approval documents available
Note: Only documents approved by the Department after November 2019 will be published above. Any documents approved before this time can be viewed on the Applicant's website.
Complaints
Want to lodge a compliance complaint about this project?
Make a ComplaintEnforcements
There are no enforcements for this project.
Inspections
There are no inspections for this project.
Note: Only enforcements and inspections undertaken by the Department from March 2020 will be shown above.
Submissions
Showing 1 - 20 of 161 submissions
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
Constructing driveways into and out of Main Avenue as the public entrance to a new coroners court and forensic pathology laboratory is totally at odds with the heritage significance of the road and the previous efforts to conserve it.
I care for the following reasons
IT WILL INCREASE TRAFFIC throughout the estate, particularly Botanica Drive, Betty Cuthbert Drive, Peppertree road, Grevillea Cres, Palm Circuit, Sussex St and Main avenue, as cars will be forced to drive through Botanica to get to / from the Court and morgue as the exit from Main avenue to Joseph St is Left hand turn (i.e. Southbound) only.
-IT WILL create parking problems, as people will park in Botanica's streets if the public entry to the court and morgue is from Main Avenue.
- IT WILL compromise the aesthetics of Main avenue, that is subject to a Heritage listing.
-IT WILL INCREASE safety risk to our children and elderly residents within the estate.
- IT WILL POTENTIALLY undervalue our homes in Botanica.
I care for the following reasons
IT WILL INCREASE TRAFFIC throughout the estate, particularly Botanica Drive, Betty Cuthbert Drive, Peppertree road, Grevillea Cres, Palm Circuit, Sussex St and Main avenue, as cars will be forced to drive through Botanica to get to / from the Court and morgue as the exit from Main avenue to Joseph St is Left hand turn (i.e. Southbound) only.
-IT WILL create parking problems, as people will park in Botanica's streets if the public entry to the court and morgue is from Main Avenue.
- IT WILL compromise the aesthetics of Main avenue, that is subject to a Heritage listing.
-IT WILL INCREASE safety risk to our children and elderly residents within the estate.
- IT WILL POTENTIALLY undervalue our homes in Botanica.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
#7545 FPCC
I would like to object to the entry/exit neing on Main Avenue. Main Avenue is listed on http://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/heritageapp/ViewHeritageItemDetails.aspx?ID=5049732 as one of tbe road and landscape elements to the heritage site of the previous Lidcombe Hospital. There is also the small Any constructions to add an entry/exit on Main Avenue will significantly destroying the heritage we tried to preserve.
The traffic report is purely statistical and does not consider the impact of the increase traffic to the community. FPCC is not location where members of the public frequently or regularly visits (such as shopping mall).
For members of public who needs to visit the FPCC, they possibly will come and go from 3 directions : Rookwood Rd, Amy Rd or Joseph St, it only makes sense if the entry/exit to FPCC is located on Weerona Rd. The traffic lights and the cross junction of Amy St/Rookwood Rd/Joseph St will provide public easy sccess to 3 directions.
I would like to object to the entry/exit neing on Main Avenue. Main Avenue is listed on http://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/heritageapp/ViewHeritageItemDetails.aspx?ID=5049732 as one of tbe road and landscape elements to the heritage site of the previous Lidcombe Hospital. There is also the small Any constructions to add an entry/exit on Main Avenue will significantly destroying the heritage we tried to preserve.
The traffic report is purely statistical and does not consider the impact of the increase traffic to the community. FPCC is not location where members of the public frequently or regularly visits (such as shopping mall).
For members of public who needs to visit the FPCC, they possibly will come and go from 3 directions : Rookwood Rd, Amy Rd or Joseph St, it only makes sense if the entry/exit to FPCC is located on Weerona Rd. The traffic lights and the cross junction of Amy St/Rookwood Rd/Joseph St will provide public easy sccess to 3 directions.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I am most concerned that a newly developed residential complex - namely 'Botanica', which has heritage status, is to be used as a thoroughfare for the new Forensic & Coroners Court and Morgue. Being a residential area, residents justly utilise the parking areas around their homes. This then results in narrow road ways - entirely suitable for a residential area but certainly not for the traffic which will result in a greatly increased traffic flow with staff and the public using the Court.
Within Botanica there is a major residential facility -Ferguson Lodge - for people with significant physical disabilities who access transport in this area in their wheelchairs. Increased traffic will affect these residents along with families who have young children who access the parks and walkways. There is also an aged population at Botanica who are able currently to enjoy walking around the area with confidence. Many people bought into Botanica for the residential nature of the Estate.
I request that serious consideration be given to replan the access needs of this new building. There is the alternative access from Weeroona Road. If the proposed project cannot be confined to the Government site which is identified for the Court and Morgue, then it should be considered for another site where it does not negatively impact on the lives of 0ver 700 families. The Botanica Estate was previously a hospital which also could not have coped with more traffic through the streets so it should not be considered now.
There is also a preschool along Main Avenue which will certainly be impacted with additional traffic on a daily basis.
There is also the probability that public parking would extend onto Main Avenue, thus making this roadway even narrower. Buses that service this area via Main Avenue will have even more difficulty than they already have in making their necessary turns when in the Botanica Estate.
Some 700-800 families will be disadvantaged if this proposal goes ahead without changes to the access to the court.
Within Botanica there is a major residential facility -Ferguson Lodge - for people with significant physical disabilities who access transport in this area in their wheelchairs. Increased traffic will affect these residents along with families who have young children who access the parks and walkways. There is also an aged population at Botanica who are able currently to enjoy walking around the area with confidence. Many people bought into Botanica for the residential nature of the Estate.
I request that serious consideration be given to replan the access needs of this new building. There is the alternative access from Weeroona Road. If the proposed project cannot be confined to the Government site which is identified for the Court and Morgue, then it should be considered for another site where it does not negatively impact on the lives of 0ver 700 families. The Botanica Estate was previously a hospital which also could not have coped with more traffic through the streets so it should not be considered now.
There is also a preschool along Main Avenue which will certainly be impacted with additional traffic on a daily basis.
There is also the probability that public parking would extend onto Main Avenue, thus making this roadway even narrower. Buses that service this area via Main Avenue will have even more difficulty than they already have in making their necessary turns when in the Botanica Estate.
Some 700-800 families will be disadvantaged if this proposal goes ahead without changes to the access to the court.
shafiqul chowdhury
Object
shafiqul chowdhury
Object
lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
the proposed Forensic pathology and Coroner's court will increase local traffic, noise and pollution. the value of the area as a residential estate will be downgraded. The perceived value of the property will fall. Security and safety of the locality will be compromised.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
Against to construct public entry and exit of Main Avenue within our community estate.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
Proposed entrance via Main Avenue will mean a profound increase in traffic on Botanica's already narrow streets. There are many families with kids in the area and the increased traffic in the estate poses a danger. For vehicles entering the Coroners court from the South and exiting to go North it is inevitable that these vehicles will make way through the estate. The simplest solution is to relocate the public entrance alongside the staff entrance on Weerona road as this road is specifically designed for such purpose. The streets of Botanica were not envisaged to handle such an increase in traffic 24 hours a day/7 days a week. Specifically the street I live on, Betty Cuthbert Drive, will see a marked increase in traffic. I urge you to see for yourself how narrow this street is and the impact increased traffic flow will have on it.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
The use of main avenue for the proposed NSW forensic pathology services will dramatically increase traffic to the local streets of Botanica estate. These streets were not originally developed for large vehicles let alone large amounts of traffic as they are narrow streets which can only fit 1 car safely down the existing roads and will lead to peak hour traffic offloading into the area e.g. Traffic will by pass main roads (i.e. Weerona road and Joseph street) and congest the residential streets of Botanica estate.
This will lead to an increase in car accidents to parked and driving cars or pedestrians accidents, increased crime rates as this estate is quiet and only incurs local resident traffic at this current point in time and noise pollution by the increase in traffic on main avenue.
This will lead to an increase in car accidents to parked and driving cars or pedestrians accidents, increased crime rates as this estate is quiet and only incurs local resident traffic at this current point in time and noise pollution by the increase in traffic on main avenue.
Man Tran
Object
Man Tran
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
The proposed entrance and exits onto Main Ave within the Botanica estate is unworkable. This will heavily increase the traffic with the narrow streets of the estate, which is currently barely able to cope with local residence traffic. Alternative entrances should be considered on Weerona road, which is much easier for traffic access.
Levent Ersan
Object
Levent Ersan
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
Once again NSW STATE GOVERNMENT is disregarding community values. There is no need for the decisions they are making we have state of the art civil engineers and civil planning experts and if this is the best they can come up with then we are not a state of the 21st century but one of communist rule. Do not increase traffic within Botanica it should be local traffic only. There are other options the development can take. We are not against progress however we must preserve the Heritage identity of Botanica. We have been residents here for 4 years and have seen the traffic increase dramatically.
soo kyung ko
Object
soo kyung ko
Object
lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
don't change botanica
glen duncan
Object
glen duncan
Object
lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
don't change botanica please !
Sui Fan Kitty Wong
Object
Sui Fan Kitty Wong
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the establishment of a three storey building Forensic Pathology and Coroner's court at Weeroona.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Jodie Fung
Object
Jodie Fung
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the establishment of a three storey building Forensic Pathology and Coroner's court at Weeroona.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Tom Fung
Object
Tom Fung
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the establishment of a three storey building Forensic Pathology and Coroner's court at Weeroona.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Joseph Fung
Object
Joseph Fung
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I object to the establishment of a three storey building Forensic Pathology and Coroner's court at Weeroona.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Using main avenue in Botanica as the public access to the new Coroner's court, despite alternate routes available will increase traffic flow within Botanica and create potential parking issues and greater risk for children. This is particularly the case, as most Botanica residents already use Main avenue and it is already busy road.
I want to keep Botanica as a quiet residential area with low traffic flow.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
This will cause too much traffic on our already narrow street. This will cause hazard to our residents especially our kids playing around. Please do not destroy our peaceful environment.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
We strongly object due to major traffic and disruption to piece and quiet in the neighbourhood.
Richard Lee
Object
Richard Lee
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
Concerning increase traffic in Botanica street and potential parking issue.
And heritage significance of Main Ave.
And heritage significance of Main Ave.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
Lidcombe
,
New South Wales
Message
I am writing to object to the proposed public entry and exit on Main Avenue. I do not object to any other aspect of the project.
Botanica estate has been built with narrow roads, especially sections of Botanica drive and many of the smaller roads. Public buses travel along Botanica Dr and make u-turns on main avenue as it is not possible to exit northbound on Joseph St from Main Ave. As Botanica Dr is so narrow when cars are parked on each side it is not possible for a car and bus to pass each other. Any increase in traffic on Botanica Dr would increase this already dangerous arrangement. This is further compounded by the fact that Central Park, a park heavily utilised by young children, runs the length of Botanica Dr. As all northbound traffic will need to travel along Botanica Dr if the public access is on Main Ave, this is a dangerous arrangement.
If Main Avenue is used as the public access then a set of traffic lights should be installed at the intersection of Main Avenue and Joseph St so that any traffic for the proposed coroners court will not have to enter Botanica estate beyond Main Ave.
It would be more appropriate, however, for public access to be off Weeroona Rd.
Botanica estate has been built with narrow roads, especially sections of Botanica drive and many of the smaller roads. Public buses travel along Botanica Dr and make u-turns on main avenue as it is not possible to exit northbound on Joseph St from Main Ave. As Botanica Dr is so narrow when cars are parked on each side it is not possible for a car and bus to pass each other. Any increase in traffic on Botanica Dr would increase this already dangerous arrangement. This is further compounded by the fact that Central Park, a park heavily utilised by young children, runs the length of Botanica Dr. As all northbound traffic will need to travel along Botanica Dr if the public access is on Main Ave, this is a dangerous arrangement.
If Main Avenue is used as the public access then a set of traffic lights should be installed at the intersection of Main Avenue and Joseph St so that any traffic for the proposed coroners court will not have to enter Botanica estate beyond Main Ave.
It would be more appropriate, however, for public access to be off Weeroona Rd.
Name Withheld
Object
Name Withheld
Object
LIDCOMBE
,
New South Wales
Message
I would like to submit my objection to the Forensic Pathology Coroner's Court car Park entrance/exit proposed in Main Ave Lidcombe Botanica.
An alternate location would be at Weeroona Rd away from residents, children,housing .
Further, Weeroona Rd has traffic light to better suit traffic flow.
I live on Main Ave and I am well aware of speeding traffic negotiating narrow car parked, blind sweeping corners.
Nineteen units (approx) are now being built in Main Ave 200 metres from my unit which will obviously create more traffic congestion also with the Onori Korean church existing next door.
An alternate location would be at Weeroona Rd away from residents, children,housing .
Further, Weeroona Rd has traffic light to better suit traffic flow.
I live on Main Ave and I am well aware of speeding traffic negotiating narrow car parked, blind sweeping corners.
Nineteen units (approx) are now being built in Main Ave 200 metres from my unit which will obviously create more traffic congestion also with the Onori Korean church existing next door.
Pagination
Project Details
Application Number
SSD-7545
Assessment Type
State Significant Development
Development Type
Hospitals, medical centres and health research facilities
Local Government Areas
Cumberland
Decision
Approved
Determination Date
Decider
Minister
Contact Planner
Name
David
Gibson