Port Waratah Coal Services - Terminal 4

The further development of our Coal Port operations is an essential factor in our economy. I fully support the project.

As a frequent visitor to the Newcastle area, I admire the long and proud history of the coal industry in the region. The T4 Terminal would provide a great opportunity for the Newcastle region to contribute to strengthening of the economy by building major infrastructure to encourage more exporting activity, while at the same time provide the community with extra job opportunities both directly and indirectly with the creation and expansion of support services.

I am in favour of the proposed T4 Development as outlined in the exhibition documents.

I believe the project will be of benefit to not only Newcastle but to the state of NSW and that we should support the mining industry in their endeavours to provide the infrastructure necessary for their operations.

I believe the environmental off set sites associated with their development are a genuine benefit to ecological diversity in areas where preservation for perpetuity is vital.

NSW Department of Planning and Infrastructure
GPO Box 39
SYDNEY NSW 2001


Dear Sir,
Re: Letter of Support for PWCS' Proposed Terminal 4 Project
I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.
Yours faithfully

Signed: David Rowland
Date: 12/11/13

I support the T4 submission due to the economic benefits that will be realised and the opportunities it will give to the Hunter.
I welcome the offer to clean up the existing site which has been a dumping ground for waste from other industries in previous years.
Additionally I believe the site is far enough removed from residential areas to have no impact on them.
I am aware and commend the plans for minimising impact on the local wildlife and land.

I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.

I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle and the Hunter region by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered significant biodiversity offset with land at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as hascaptive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog.
* PWCS has designed T4 to contain world best dust and noise mitigation measures.
* The project funds the capping and containment of contaminants within the site, thus saving public money for these works.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand. While I have concerns about the long term use of coal, I understand it is a resource for energy supply while low carbon renewable energy sources are developed.

As a university student studying engineering I can see how big a help this will be to the local community including my entire cohort. Given the current economic climate numerous current and previous students whom I have known are finding it very difficult to find work. This is bad for not only the graduates who have spent a good deal of money and time studying this to essentially do whatever job comes up (not in the industry) but also the current students who would be able to gain valuable experience BEFORE they proceed out into industry and manage their own projects. This will not only help numerous companies in the local area who are directly or indirectly involved but also to firm Newcastle's stance as a world leader in not only bulk goods handling but also in engineering. I fully support T4 as I believe it will be a huge benefit to the local economy into the future.

I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.

NSW Department of Planning and Infrastructure
GPO Box 39
SYDNEY NSW 2001


Dear Sir,
Re: Letter of Support for PWCS' Proposed Terminal 4 Project
I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.
Yours faithfully

Renee Fleming
12 November 2013

I am in favour of this development, the coal industry has been part of the Hunter Valley's economy for well over 150 years and is currently an essential part of the NSW economy.

It is essential that the industry utiises the latest and best facilites and this is an example of industry adopting the best environmental, construction and operation concepts.

The new terminal will provide greater certainty of coal chain performance and continue PWCS' relevant and positive position in the economies of NSW in general and the Hunter Valley in particular.

I wish to submit my support as I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter and NSW. It will not only generate local employment and business opportunities during the construction phase but will also provide enduring benefits from future operations.

From an environmental point of view, I am unsure of the level of commitment from the NSW State Government for capping and containment of the dangerous industrial waste that is already present at the proposed T4 site. Surely this work is best funded from the private sector to ensure that this important work gets completed in a more timely manner. Also, PWCS' commitment to securing the large volume of relevant offset land should be commended.

Lastly, I have a great level of confidence and trust in PWCS as history shows they are a responsible member of the community in Newcastle.

Newcastle needs sustainable employment opportunities. T4 represents a substantial investment in the future of the Hunter Valley and employment for our families. Port Waratah Coal Services are leaders in the field of safety and environmental responsibility.

All developments have an environmental impact, from the construction of a house through to the construction of major infrastructure. These impacts have to be weighed up against the benefits of the development, otherwise no development would ever be allowed to take place.

It is clear that the development of a fourth coal terminal in the Port of Newcastle will have an environmental impact. However, it seems as though the proponent has to gone to great lengths to mitigate or ameliorate these impacts so that they contained below acceptable limits and comply with government policy. Two examples include the extensive measures to address contamination legacies, and the proposed mitigation measures and offsets to address ecological impacts.

I note that the proposed coal terminal is located on land that has been zoned and allocated for port related development. It seems to be consistent with a range of state and national planning policies relating to port development.

When weighing up the impacts against the benefits of the development of a fourth coal terminal in the Port of Newcastle and considering its applicability with state and national planning policies, it is my view that the benefits of the terminal significantly outweigh its impacts.

I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.

My company, its employees and I have been involved with developments at Kooragang Island and in the city of Newcastle and in the Hunter Valley for over 30 years.

I am aware that the PWCS T4 project will provide a significant economic boost to our region during its construction and will continue to provide long term employment and local business support during its operations.

I am aware that PWCS has already delivered a biodiversity offset package with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in research and breeding programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. These offset initiatives offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of the construction of the T4 terminal.

I am aware that the T4 Terminal's design brief includes mandatory design provisions governing the dust and noise characteristics of the proposed facility, and that these provisions focus on the construction and operational containment and suppression of dust and noise such that Government guidelines are adhered to and acceptable levels are not breached.

I am aware that the T4 Site on Kooragang Island is an area containing significant contamination from non-PWCS related industrial activities, and that the proposed T4 facility's construction includes provisions to cap and contain this contamination. I am aware that the cost of this containment is to be included in the cost of the T4 development which is not funded by the Government and, as such, the containment works and the benefits to the environment will be provided at no cost to the public.

I am aware that PWCS mandates that all employees, contractors, suppliers and contributors to its developments and operations are required to ensure that the environment, public health and safety and the local community's best interests are maintained without compromise. I am also aware that such mandate is stringently policed by PWCS and its representatives constantly. To this end I am aware that PWCS is a proven responsible developer and operator.

I am aware that PWCS has operated at Kooragang Island for more than 30 years and that their development and operations has continued to contribute to the local economy throughout that period. PWCS is a large employer and continually provides opportunities for our youth in their professional development and the future security of our Hunter Valley Community.

Our business survives as a direct result of the Hunter Valley Coal Chain's continued viability and operations, including its growth and development. This circumstance is replicated enormously in our business community and the PWCS T4 development is a considered to be a further opportunity to contribute to and support this business survival, which directly contributes to the support of the community in which we live and work.

NSW Department of Planning and Infrastructure
GPO Box 39
SYDNEY NSW 2001


Dear Sir,
Re: Letter of Support for PWCS' Proposed Terminal 4 Project
I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.
Yours faithfully

I support the project

We fully support this project. We have found PWCS to be a very ethical business and very efficient in the supply chain. There is much discussion on the impacts of coal and this creates opportunity for academia and business to create new industry rather than stifle development. We are particularly impressed with PWCS remediation of contaminated land.

Well may they and the City of Newcastle prosper.

I understand PWCS' Preferred Project Report (PPR) for the proposed Terminal 4 (T4) is currently on public exhibition. Accordingly, I wish to submit my support for the project for the following reasons:
* I believe the project will provide significant economic benefit to Newcastle, the Hunter region and NSW by generating local employment and business opportunity during construction of the Terminal and during future operations.
* PWCS has delivered a significant biodiversity offset package (approximately 850 ha) with land secured at Tomago, Ellalong and Brundee, as well as investing in captive breeding and research programs for the Green and Golden Bell Frog. The committed offset initiatives more than adequately offset the environmental impact on the T4 site as a result of construction of the terminal.
* I believe that PWCS has designed T4 to contain "state of the art" dust and noise mitigation measures, which is supported by appropriate modelling predicting cumulative levels of dust and noise as a result of T4 to remain within Government guidelines for health and amenity.
* Construction of the T4 terminal provides a significant opportunity for the private sector to fund the capping and containment of contaminants within the proposed T4 site. Without private sector funding such as that from PWCS' T4 project, the accountability for capping and containment of contaminants rests with the NSW State Government.
* I have a great deal of confidence and trust in PWCS as they have proven to be a responsible developer, operator and active member of the community in Newcastle as history shows. PWCS has been operating and expanding their business in Newcastle for over 30 years contributing greatly to the local economy. The opportunity they provide as a large employer for training and jobs for young people and security for families cannot be understated.
* The coal industry has historically made a significant contribution to the economic development of the Hunter, NSW and Australia. Approval of the T4 project continues that history and allows us to accommodate future growth in coal export from Newcastle according to resource demand.
Yours faithfully