Junction Rivers Wind Farm (formerly Burrawong Wind Farm)

Your work is a joke. You are killing peoples way of life and livelihoods. You are a disgrace of a government instead of offering your bribe money to the farmers land tell them the truth about what you are putting on there property. Absolute joke.

I suggest take your windmills to old power coal fired power stations where all the infrastructure is already there, eg. power lines etc.
instead of interfering with rural farms & people who are a minority that just have this situation forced upon them. It's not right.

Item 3.1.1 of the EPBC Referral Application Number 01921 dated 10/7/23 notes that the land upon which the project is to be constructed is zoned RU1 Primary Production under the Murray Local Environmental Plan 2011.

This project is in breach of Article 2.1(b) of the 2015 Paris Agreement which states: "Increasing the ability to adapt to the adverse impacts of climate change and foster climate resilience and low greenhouse gas emissions development, in a manner that does not threaten food production."
Therefore, the construction of wind turbines on Land that is zoned as RU1 Primary Production should not be permitted.

Extract: "The Subject Land is located within the Murray River Council LGA, approximately 15 km south of Balranald and approximately 10 km north of Kyalite. The Proposed Action is located in the South-West REZ. The Subject Land contains a 220 kV transmission line which runs through the northern portion of the Subject Land, the ‘Project Energy Connect’ transmission line (currently under construction) is to be located directly north of the 220kV line. A small portion of the Subject Land borders with the Yanga National Park, while the remaining surrounding environment is agricultural land.
The Subject Land is zoned as RU1 Primary Production under the Murray Local Environmental Plan 2011. The surrounding properties are also zoned RU1 Primary Production, with Yanga National Park zoned as E1 – National Parks and Nature Reserve".

Also two EPBC Act listed species have been recorded within the Project Area, including the Regent Parrot ( Polytelis anthopeplus monarchoides) listed as Vulnerable under the EPBC Act, and the Major Mitchell’s Cockatoo ( Lophochroa leadbeateri leadbeateri ) listed as Endangered under the EPBC Act.
While the Migratory listed Fork-tailed Swift (Apus pacificus) was considered in initial risk assessments as having potential to occur occasionally within the Subject Land, it was not recorded in 24 months of utilisation surveys."
Wind turbines are bird killers. The bird carcasses attract foxes and other feral animals such as feral cats, wild dogs and feral pigs. Foxes, feral cats. wild dogs and feral pigs don’t discriminate and kill domestic animals, small livestock and small native mammals. Indeed feral pigs wait when ewes are giving birth and the devour the newly born lambs!
The proposed Junction Rivers Wind Project would not be conducive to the conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity.
Demolition and Rehabilitation Bonds.
Wind, solar and BESS Companies are not required to provide Demolition and Rehabilitation Bonds. The Applicant Company, JUNCTION RIVERS PTY LIMITED is a wholly owned subsidiary of JUNCTION RIVERS HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED. The Applicant Company (Lessee) enters into a leasing agreement with the host/landowner (Lessor) to enable construction of the 96 wind turbines on the host/landowners property. Without a Demolition or Rehabilitation Bond there is no incentive for the Applicant company to demolish and remove the 96 wind turbines and rehabilitate the land to its original zoning of RU1 Primary Production. The 2015 Australian Senate Select Committee on Wind Turbines that the cost of demolition of a wind turbine was in the order of $380,000. The present day cost of demolition of the now larger wind turbines has been independently estimated to be between $450,000 and $600,000. Therefore, at today's cost, the demolition and removal of the proposed 96 wind turbines would be, (at the lower rate of $450,000), $43,200,000 (Forty three million two hundred thousand dollars)! As previously stated, there is no incentive for the Applicant Company to demolish and remove the 96 wind turbines. It is plausible that the Applicant Company pays dividends to the beneficial owner, the Holding Company, from the income generated by the Applicant Company's during the operational life of the project such that at the end of operational life of the project, the Applicant Company (Lessee) would not have the financial capability to demolish and remove the 96 wind turbines and would be liquidated, thus leaving the host/landowner (Lessor) with 96 wind turbines on their land and the cost of demolishing and removing them. The Holding Company, not being a party to the Lease Agreement, would have no responsibility for the demolition and removal of the 96 wind turbines.
Caveat Emptor!

I oppose wind generating power.
Quoting the word of Dick Smith: 'there is no need to destroy the environment to save the environment'.

The close proximity to the yanga national park with its large number of migratory birds,the effects on neighbouring farmers chemical applications,visual impact,high risk of fire starting and the negative effects on neighbouring land values are the reasons for my objection.

We don't need to destroy the environment to save the environment.

I object to this project because efforts to protect and preserve the environment should not involve actions that ultimately harm it or undermine the very goals we seek to achieve. "We should not destroy the environment to save the environment".

I am getting increasingly concerned of the number of renewable Energy Projects on the Riverina Plains planned for our region
The Junction Rivers Wind Farm EIS makes very little comment on the cumulative impact this project will have on our environment. Needless to mention the significant disruption it will have on the migratory bird population and the native grasslands of the area
The EIS lacks detail on how it is to access the grid its lines of transmission to grid/ substation.
The impact this project will have on neighbouring properties needs further acknowledgement, with a more detailed Near Neighbour Benefit Sharing arrangement as outlined in the most recent NSW Planning Guidelines.

Please refer to the attached separate submissions for the Wind Works and for the BESS's

I object unreservedly to this project.
During my 35 years doing agronomic advisory work in the region, where this project is being proposed, i have never seen such unprofessional behaviour by the proponent companies employees.
This in regard to responding in my request to confirming that there would be an absolute guarantee that there would be No drift of volatile herbicides onto highly susceptible adjacent horticultural permanent plantings.
These discussions involved a number of the projects employees and this issue was NEVER resolved.
During the discussions I put forward the impact on my cropping farmers businesses in a financial only impact and my figures showed in excess of $160,000.00 per annum in direct costs.
The proponents employees responded and asked for the specific compounds that would need to be changed , which I supplied the proponents employees to demonstrate the impact.
I NEVER had a response after I supplied this information.
What is the project proponent hiding??
I would hope that this project is denied.

I object to the divide and suffering that it will cause the farming community

The increased traffic going past our place and the grazing country that is going to be destroyed by these going up on peoples country they kill so much wildlife as well so no I wouldn’t want to be looking at them

I’m writing to say that this project should not go ahead. Please done destroy the environment for no gain.

To Junction Rivers Wind Farm Project Manager,

I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposed wind farm project near Kyalite. As a frequent visitor to this area, where my family and I enjoy camping and vacationing, I am deeply concerned about the potential impact this development would have on the natural beauty and ecological balance of the region.

The area where the wind farm is planned is known for its pristine landscapes, rich wildlife, and tranquil environment. The installation of large wind turbines could significantly alter the scenery and disrupt the natural habitats that are vital for local wildlife. Moreover, the visual impact of these structures could diminish the very qualities that attract visitors to the area, potentially affecting local tourism and recreation.

In addition to environmental concerns, I am troubled by the way this project is affecting the local community. There is a growing divide among residents, with some supporting the project for its potential economic benefits and others opposing it due to its impact on the landscape and quality of life. This division has led to a noticeable shift in the community’s mood, creating tensions and reducing the sense of cohesion that has long characterized this area. Such discord not only affects community relationships but also detracts from the peaceful experience that many, including myself, value during our visits.

While I understand the need for renewable energy sources and support efforts to address climate change, I believe that this project might not be the best fit for this particular location. I urge you to consider alternative sites that would have a less intrusive impact on the environment and the communities that cherish this region.

Thank you for considering my concerns. I hope that you will take these factors into account and explore other options that would allow for the preservation of the unique character of kyalite while still advancing our shared goal of sustainable energy.

Sincerely,
Maddie

Teagan Hayes
1200A McIvor Highway
Junortoun, VIC, 3551
[email protected]
02.08.2024


To whom it may concern,

I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposed wind farm project in Kyalite, NSW. As a frequent visitor to this charming small town, where I enjoy camping, boating, skiing, and bird watching, I have serious concerns about the potential impacts of this development.

The proposed site for the wind farm is located in an area that is highly valued for it’s natural beauty and recreational opportunities. The installation of large wind turbines could significantly alter the landscape, disrupting the serene environment that is crucial for activities such as bird watching and outdoor sports. The visual impact of these turbines may diminish the aesthetic appeal that attracts visitors to the town.

Additionally, the local ecosystem supports a variety of bird species that are a key attraction for nature enthusiasts. The presence of wind turbines poses a risk to these birds, potentially leading to collisions and disrupting their habitats. This could have a detrimental effect on both the local wildlife and the enjoyment of bird watching for visitors like myself.

The potential for noise pollution and visual intrusion also raises concerns. The noise generated by wind turbines could disrupt the peaceful atmosphere of the town, which is an essential part of the camping and skiing experience. Furthermore, the turbines’ presence could affect the overall ambiance that makes this location a desirable destination for outdoor activities.

Moreover, the impact on local infrastructure and property values must be considered. The construction of the wind farm could lead to increased traffic and strain on local roads, potentially affecting the quality of life for residents and visitors. There is also concern about the potential decrease in property values due to the perceived negative impact of the wind turbines on the scenic beauty of the area.

While I fully support renewable energy and recognize it’s importance in addressing climate change, I believe that this particular location is not suitable for a wind farm. I urge you to consider alternative sites that would not compromise the natural beauty, wildlife, and recreational opportunities that make Kyalite, NSW a special place for many.

Thank you for considering my concerns. I hope that these issues will be taken into account, and that a more suitable location for the wind farm will be identified.

Sincerely,

TEAGAN HAYES

I blatantly object to the Junction Rivers Wind Farm proposal of 96- 300m high wind turbines that will be constructed adjacent to our family owned cropping property.
Please find attached a letter outlining the reasons for our objections.
Application Number SSD30448824.
THE WAY NEIHBOURING FARMERS OF WIND TURBINES SEE IT ...
YOU THE GOVERNMENT DON'T MIND WERE YOU PUT THESE MONSTROSITIES AND WE THE NEIGHBOURS DONT SEEM TO MATTER!
The impact of Windfarms popping up in prime agricultural cropping land is poor decision making on the Governments behalf.
The industrial construction of these monstrosities will increase costs to our farm. Crop & aerial spraying will increase, we will pay higher insurance premiums, higher crop insurance & it will devalue our land,& have visual & audible effects. The sheer size of these things are as high as the Eiffel tower in Paris!
This has already caused disruption and division to our township- GREED being the name of the game for a small minority in the community! and the neighbours being accused of being jealous!
I sincerely hope, common sense prevails and this project is squashed.

We should not destroy the environment to save the environment.

Please don’t go ahead and destroy the environment for no gain with this wind farm.

Objection to River Wind Farm Development

I am writing to formally object to the proposed development of the Junction Rivers Wind Farm. My objection is based on the following concerns:

1. Lack of Consultation
The consultation process for the River Wind Farm development has been inadequate. Many community members, including local residents and stakeholders, were not given sufficient opportunity to provide input or express their concerns. A project of this magnitude requires thorough and transparent engagement with the community to ensure that all voices are heard and considered. The lack of meaningful consultation undermines the principles of democratic decision-making and fails to address the legitimate concerns of those who will be most affected by the development.

2. Socio-Economic Impacts
The development of the Junction Rivers Wind Farm will have significant socio-economic impacts on the local community. The construction and operation of the wind farm may lead to increased noise pollution, visual intrusion, and potential health issues for residents living in close proximity to the turbines. On a broader scale, the decrease in property values associated with these development and the impacts on all municipal rates has not been stated or addressed.

Moreover, the economic benefits of the wind farm, such as job creation and local investment, have not been clearly demonstrated. Without a comprehensive analysis of the long-term economic benefits and potential drawbacks, it is difficult to justify the development based on economic grounds.

3. Loss of Cropping Land
The proposed site for the River Wind Farm includes valuable agricultural land currently used for cropping. This land is crucial for local farmers and the broader agricultural economy. The loss of cropping land will reduce the availability of fertile soil for food production, negatively impacting local food security and the livelihoods of farmers who rely on this land for their income.

4. Unsuitability for Grazing Animals
The proposal identifies grazing as an alternate to cropping. The semi arid environment is most suited to the cropping regime. To suggest grazing is an oversight and reinforces the developers don't understand the climate and suitability of land for particular agricultural pursuits.

I am objecting this project due to the fact that WindLabs has been unable to show evidence of the impact that the wind turbines will have on local wildlife in the Kyalite area. Also failing to provide evidence of the affects that this project could have on the farmers who work and live next to where the proposed site for the wind turbines is.